Opinion

Blunder-mania is coming for the GOP. Can the 2016 candidates avoid the smackdown?

Republican presidential candidates have a major media problem on their hands — and it has nothing to do with partisan bias

Republican presidential candidates have a major media problem on their hands, and it has nothing to do with partisan bias.

Between the day they announce their candidacy and the night their debates begin, they will draw little to no media attention unless they blunder.

Blunders — be they bursts of anger at interviewers or interpretative gaffes about the Iraq War — will be the central organizing principle of media coverage. There will of course be plenty of excellent journalism committed along the way, but it will be read by people whose minds are already made up, and it shall generally be forgotten. (There's usually one exemption per cycle: In 2007 and 2008, Ron Brownstein divided the Obama and Clinton coalitions by employing a great metaphor: Hillary was supported by beer-track voters; Obama was supported by wine-track voters.)

For Republican candidates with national images — Jeb Bush, Chris Christie, perhaps Bobby Jindal — the downside potential for their favorability ratings among Republican primary voters is significantly greater than the chance that they'll finish the fallow season with a favorable glow at all. For others, like Scott Walker, media attention to blunders might seem helpful, in the way that Republicans like to capitalize off of their own base's resentment with the press. But Fox News, too, is not immune to this observation. Jeb Bush's Iraq War circumlocution was born there, and in his effort to clean it up, he took to conservative talk radio.

What to do? Hillary Clinton's approach — to ignore the media and let surrogates deal with the media's blunder-based coverage model — won't work for the GOP. For one thing, Clinton is a known commodity, as basic to politics as steel is to cars. For another, the major "thing" — call it a knock against her — that people know about Clinton is that she's a Clinton. Fortunately, her Clinton-ness has been factored into how voters think of her, and even more fortunately for her, it is marginal to how well voters might assess her as a president. Bush, on the other hand, has to deal with his Bush-iness, which the blunder-based coverage model will never get enough of. This is probably the most obvious thing I've ever written, but neither Republicans nor Democrats feel good about George W. Bush's policies. (We like him as a person, and as a painter, perhaps, but as a president…)

The candidates could try not to blunder, but that's not really possible. Just what constitutes blundering differs from day to day. If Marco Rubio gives a speech about immigration, departures from orthodoxy are going to be labeled as blunders, requiring newscyclettes upon newscyclettes to explain. Pundits are always asked if candidates made mistakes by doing whatever they just did, which presupposes that they always make mistakes.

It's quite annoying to be a presidential candidate. I'm glad I'm not one of them.

More From...

Picture of Marc AmbinderMarc Ambinder
Read All
The cyber debate goes public
Marc Ambinder
Marc Ambinder

The cyber debate goes public

How would America verify North Korea's denuclearization?
Trump shows the document he signed with Kim
Analysis

How would America verify North Korea's denuclearization?

The NSA knew about cellphone surveillance around the White House 6 years ago
The White House.
Analysis

The NSA knew about cellphone surveillance around the White House 6 years ago

The transformation of Kim Jong Un
President Trump and Kim Jong Un.
Analysis

The transformation of Kim Jong Un

Recommended

Pelosi: SCOTUS needs lesson on 'birds and the bees'
Nancy Pelosi.
the fate of roe

Pelosi: SCOTUS needs lesson on 'birds and the bees'

Why Kevin McCarthy won't be speaker
Kevin McCarthy.
Picture of Joel MathisJoel Mathis

Why Kevin McCarthy won't be speaker

House reaches deal to try and avoid shutdown
Capitol building and christmas tree.
crisis halfway averted

House reaches deal to try and avoid shutdown

Colbert's Late Show turns the House GOP's disarray into a Real Housewives promo
House GOP Islamophobia drama
GOP in disarray

Colbert's Late Show turns the House GOP's disarray into a Real Housewives promo

Most Popular

Late night hosts riff on Omicron
Cyber Monday on The Late Show
Last Night on Late Night

Late night hosts riff on Omicron

Police reportedly seize hard drives from Marilyn Manson's home
Marilyn Manson
raid

Police reportedly seize hard drives from Marilyn Manson's home

7 cartoons about Thanksgiving inflation
Political Cartoon.
Feature

7 cartoons about Thanksgiving inflation