The lessons of Larry Hogan

A GOP governor in the ultra-blue state of Maryland is poised to win re-election next week — and in all likelihood it won't even be close.

A GOP governor in the ultra-blue state of Massachusetts is also poised to win re-election next week — and it all likelihood it won't even be close.

In neighboring Vermont — land of Bernie Sanders and Howard Dean! — an incumbent Republican governor is also comfortably ahead of his Democratic challenger.

The Week

Escape your echo chamber. Get the facts behind the news, plus analysis from multiple perspectives.

SUBSCRIBE & SAVE

Sign up for The Week's Free Newsletters

Join more than 350,000 subscribers and keep yourself informed with a selection of The Week’s most interesting, enlightening and entertaining stories - plus daily puzzles.

Join more than 350,000 subscribers and keep yourself informed with a selection of The Week’s most interesting, enlightening and entertaining stories - plus daily puzzles.

Sign up

Finally, a GOP candidate is within striking distance of winning the governor's race in reliably blue Oregon. In all likelihood, it will be close.

What are Larry Hogan, Charlie Baker, Phil Scott, and Knute Buehler doing right? How are these Republicans surviving, even thriving, amid an anti-Trump blue wave of uncertain magnitude?

Before we get to all that, let me set the table by reiterating my longstanding beef with the "purple" politics (fiscally conservative, socially inclusive) of the business elite — because I know that's exactly what you're thinking these Republicans are doing right. Yet outside of Wall Street, Washington, D.C., and Silicon Valley, the actual constituency for purple politics is a lot smaller than it seems. Wall Street, Washington, and Silicon Valley have a lot of money, ample access to the media, and, thus, a very loud megaphone.

So what gives? Does the seeming success of Baker, Buehler, Scott, and Hogan suggest that purple politics has a real future after all?

If you're excited by this prospect, I have some bad news: You have to squint pretty damn hard to see the "fiscally conservative" half of these paladins of purple. Indeed, these Republicans look a lot like Democrats.

Back in April, the editors of the Baltimore Sun chortled at Hogan's astonishingly successful partisan makeover in all but party identification:

In Massachusetts, the story is much the same. Joshua Miller writes in The Boston Globe, in a nearly identical tone of bait-and-switch irony:

In Oregon, the record is a bit more muddled. Buehler, an affable orthopedic surgeon originally from the Midwest, is pro-choice and pro-gay rights, but is wishy-washy on ObamaCare, guns, and environmental issues. Yet it's important to note that the Oregon gubernatorial race is turning mostly on local issues like homelessness and education funding. In Vermont, Gov. Scott glumly succumbed to tax increases in the last state budget and approved restrictive new gun laws. Of our four exemplars of purple, Buehler and Scott are most deftly threading the ideological needle in a way that close observers of national politics might recognize.

Is there anything to be gleaned from these races? Do they point a toward a Republican politics that doesn't require a devil's bargain with the forces of white ethnonationalism? Most Republicans on the ground would tell you no. They will tell you that, in local and state races, rank-and-file GOP voters understand the different contexts and adjust their ideological demands accordingly. They will tell you that blue-state GOP governors have distanced themselves from President Trump in a way that Republicans in other states simply cannot. They will tell you that, obviously, Republicans can win national elections without winning Oregon, Maryland, Massachusetts, and Vermont.

But Democrats are surging anew in the Midwest, potentially signaling that the gains Trump made there might be erased in 2020. They are making inroads in deep-red Tennessee while embracing gun rights and Brett Kavanaugh, yes, but also while opposing Republican fealty to corporations and its obsession with repealing ObamaCare. Without his Rust Belt crossovers, Trump is likely toast. And so Republicans will be left with a choice: Will they finally concede that their plutocratic positions on taxes, spending, and health care are unpopular as hell? Or will they double down on the race-baiting, like they are right now?

After next week's midterm election, it's very likely that the Republicans left standing will be the most stalwart Trumpists. Except for our blue-state outliers underneath the national radar. Their success, if it comes to pass, will owe not to their straddling a just-so purple line between fiscal conservatism and social inclusiveness. It will come because, on economics, blue is simply more popular.