Spain and the Hispanic World: an expansive and eccentric exhibition

In 1882, Archer M. Huntington, the son of an American railroad tycoon, made his first visit to Europe and found a book about Spanish gypsies in a Liverpool bookshop, said Adrian Searle in The Guardian. “Spain must be much more interesting than Liverpool,” he wrote in his diary.

It was the beginning of a lifelong passion, which saw Huntingdon amass the most comprehensive collection of Spanish and Hispanic art outside of Spain. In 1908, he opened the Hispanic Society Museum & Library in New York to display his treasures.

The museum is currently closed for refurbishment, and the Royal Academy has taken the opportunity to borrow more than 150 of its best pieces. “Sunny Spain and black, severe Catholic Spain; the folkloric Spain of peasants and bullfighters, bodegas and Carmen; the Spain of empire and conquest, the Moorish Spain of Al-Andalus” – they’re all here.

Subscribe to The Week

Escape your echo chamber. Get the facts behind the news, plus analysis from multiple perspectives.

SUBSCRIBE & SAVE

Sign up for The Week's Free Newsletters

From our morning news briefing to a weekly Good News Newsletter, get the best of The Week delivered directly to your inbox.

From our morning news briefing to a weekly Good News Newsletter, get the best of The Week delivered directly to your inbox.

Sign up

There are “great things” in this exhibition: a “small and intimate” portrait of a young girl by Velázquez, possibly of his granddaughter; Goya’s full-length 1797 portrait of the Duchess of Alba wearing a “showy” lower-class costume; Giovanni Vespucci’s 1526 World Map “with its elisions and vast blanks and unknown parts”. But it’s a curious show overall: “grim and gorgeous, extensive and rushed, overwhelming in its scope”, yet “oddly truncated”.

“Sometimes it’s too much,” agreed Chloë Ashby in The Times. The exhibition covers the art and culture of Spain and Latin America from the prehistoric era to the early 20th century, and the many cultures that shaped it. You can see the metalwork and pottery of the prehistoric Iberians, the craft of Muslim artisans. “Three rooms are set aside for the maps and decorative arts of colonial Latin America.”

The Spanish Golden Age is represented by the work of some of its greatest painters, such as El Greco and Francisco de Zurbaran. At the end of the show, there are a series of colossal canvases by the impressionist Joaquín Sorolla. Commissioned in the early 20th century for the Hispanic Society, they depict different regions of Spain, “bursting with colour, bathed in light”.

There are “Sorollas aplenty”, said Hettie Judah in The i Paper – “beach scenes full of clingy garments and wet skin, a garden abundant with garish blooms”. They are typical of this rather eccentric collection, that speaks perhaps as much of “the obsessions of its owner” as of the subjects it celebrates.

‘Trapped in another era’

The show does invoke the sense of being “trapped in another era”, before museums felt obliged to present carefully “designed experiences”, said Mark Hudson in The Independent – “when it was enough simply to put interesting stuff in a room and leave it up to the visitor to take it or leave it”. But that’s no bad thing, given the sheer quantity of fascinating artefacts here.

Where else would you see a “fabulous array of renaissance doorknockers in the form of mythical beasts and birds”? Or a lacquered 17th century Mexican writing desk covered in Aztec decorative figures? Or a “troubling” casta (caste) painting entitled Mestizo and Indian Produce a Coyote (1715) that depicts a mixed race man and his native American wife and child with disgust, exhibiting the Spanish colonists’ obsession with racial purity. Overall, though, “it’s the exuberant impurity of many of its exhibits that provides this exhibition’s best moments”.

Royal Academy, London (020-7300 8090, royalacademy.org.uk) Until 10 May