Controversy is brewing over a lawsuit involving Hermès' luxury bags
The lawsuit alleges the company only sells bags to people with a 'sufficient purchase history'
Hermès is one of the world's best-known — and most expensive — luxury retailers, with products on the brand's website ranging from hundreds to thousands of dollars. However, a new lawsuit against the company is opening debate over whether customers have a legal right to buy Hermès' products.
The lawsuit, filed in California on March 19, revolves around Hermès' Birkin handbag. An infamous symbol of wealth, the Birkin is one of the most exclusive luxury items in the world. Sold only at Hermès' retail stores, the cheapest variant of the Birkin starts at $10,145; higher-end versions have been sold for more than $100,000. The lawsuit alleges that Hermès only sells Birkins to customers with a "sufficient purchase history," claiming that one of the plaintiffs was "coerced into purchasing ancillary products in order to obtain access to Hermès Birkin bags." This represents a violation of antitrust and competition laws, the lawsuit claims, because of the "unique desirability, incredible demand and low supply" of Birkin bags.
Reaction to the lawsuit has been mixed. There has been some support for the lawsuit's antitrust allegations, but others claim that the bigger picture is more complex.
Subscribe to The Week
Escape your echo chamber. Get the facts behind the news, plus analysis from multiple perspectives.
Sign up for The Week's Free Newsletters
From our morning news briefing to a weekly Good News Newsletter, get the best of The Week delivered directly to your inbox.
From our morning news briefing to a weekly Good News Newsletter, get the best of The Week delivered directly to your inbox.
Legal experts are 'dubious on the suit's merits'
Many people in the legal field are "dubious on the suit's merits" because Hermès "does not control the robust secondhand market for its bags," Amanda Mull said for The Atlantic. While rare, there are instances where "people sometimes do just walk into a boutique off the street, ask nicely, and get lucky."
While the Birkin bag is extraordinarily expensive, this is because they are "actually pretty rare, compared with the products made by the brand's closest competitors," said Mull. It can take up to 40 hours to manufacture a single Birkin bag, and this helps "Hermès and its fans spin a compelling tale about why its prices — high even among luxury brands, though not by as wide a margin as they once were — are justifiable," said Mull.
When it comes to the lawsuit, Hermès "has it in the bag," Susan Scafidi, the academic director at Fordham University's Fashion Law Institute, said to The Washington Post. This is because the luxury brand "doesn't tell buyers how much they need to spend to gain access to the Birkin," making it harder for the plaintiffs to pinpoint a specific instance in which Hermès is breaking antitrust laws.
Additionally, a judge is "more likely to rule that a sales practice violates the law when the item in question can be deemed a necessity," Douglas Hand, a lawyer who works with high-end fashion brands, said to The New York Times. This includes products such as medications and other medical items, but there are "not as many reasons for why every consumer needs access to a Birkin bag or any specific luxury item."
The law 'says it's illegal'
Even though a Birkin bag might not be a necessity, when it comes to Hermès' practices, the "law says it's illegal," Shaun Setareh, a lawyer representing the plaintiffs in the case, said to the Times. This is because Hermès is "preconditioning buying other products — scarves, belts, shoes, perfume, jewelry — before they give you the opportunity to buy a Birkin."
This lawsuit is arguing that Hermès isn't just keeping the bags exclusive, but that the "setup doubles as a sneaky moneymaking scheme," Clint Rainey said for Fast Company. The company achieves this by "forcing customers to buy a litany of items they don't necessarily want in order to purchase the item they do want." This allows the lawsuit to argue that Hermès' sales process is "anti-competitive and violates the Sherman [Antitrust] Act and California state laws."
No matter how the courtroom antics play out, the luxury goods industry will be "watching the lawsuit's progression to gauge the wider implications, as other high-end brands evaluate whether their own tactics could potentially line up with the legal definition" that violates antitrust, said Joan Kennedy for CNN. But while the law itself may be unclear on the matter, Hermès is "driven by supply, not demand," Erwan Rambourg, the global head of consumer and retail research at HSBC, said to CNN. "You buy luxury to be part of the club. That's what it's about. It defeats the purpose if the club is open to everyone."
Create an account with the same email registered to your subscription to unlock access.
Sign up for Today's Best Articles in your inbox
A free daily email with the biggest news stories of the day – and the best features from TheWeek.com
Justin Klawans has worked as a staff writer at The Week since 2022. He began his career covering local news before joining Newsweek as a breaking news reporter, where he wrote about politics, national and global affairs, business, crime, sports, film, television and other Hollywood news. Justin has also freelanced for outlets including Collider and United Press International.
-
King Charles portrait: 'mystique' or 'monstrosity'?
Talking Point While the artist hoped to portray the 'magic' of the monarchy, critics have lambasted the 'spooky' work
By Sorcha Bradley, The Week UK Published
-
What does the Green Party stand for?
The Explainer The party's growing prominence has sparked Labour into action ahead of the general election
By Richard Windsor, The Week UK Published
-
'Israeli officers chafe over lack of postwar plan'
Today's Newspapers A roundup of the headlines from the US front pages
By The Week Staff Published
-
Will college Gaza protests tip the US election?
Talking Point Gaza protests on U.S. campuses pose problems for Biden like the ones that hurt Lyndon B. Johnson in the '60s
By Harold Maass, The Week US Published
-
Downtown St. Louis is in a real estate 'doom loop'
Under the Radar The city is rife with abandoned buildings and vacant lots, with its real estate market in dire straits
By Justin Klawans, The Week US Published
-
How will the FTC's ban on noncompete agreements affect the workforce?
The explainer Short answer: Competition will only get fiercer
By Devika Rao, The Week US Published
-
American Airlines pilots are warning of a 'significant spike' in safety issues
In the Spotlight The pilot's union listed 'problematic trends' they say are affecting the airline's fleet
By Justin Klawans, The Week US Published
-
Why is Tesla stumbling?
In the Spotlight More competition, confusion about the future and a giant pay package for Elon Musk
By Joel Mathis, The Week US Published
-
Can Trump get a fair trial?
Talking Points Donald Trump says he can't get a fair trial in heavily Democratic Manhattan as his hush money case starts
By Harold Maass, The Week US Published
-
The wine industry is getting pressed as young people drink less
Under the Radar The once-dominating drink is not aging well
By Anya Jaremko-Greenwold, The Week US Published
-
The largest insurance company payouts
In The Spotlight Fights over insurance have been in the spotlight following the collapse of the Francis Scott Key Bridge in Baltimore
By Justin Klawans, The Week US Published