Good One: an 'intensely compelling' coming-of-age tale
India Donaldson's 'quietly devastating' debut feature about a teenage girl's life-changing camping trip
In cinema, we tend to assume that life-changing moments will be seismic – "white-knuckle scenes of heightened drama that shift the very axis of reality", said Wendy Ide in The Observer. But in her "quietly devastating" debut feature, India Donaldson suggests that "the events that shift the direction of our lives" can be so slight as to go almost unnoticed.
The film stars Lily Collias (remarkable, in her first lead role) as 17-year-old Sam, who is roped into joining her downbeat divorced dad Chris (James Le Gros) and his best buddy Matt (Danny McCarthy) on a hiking trip in the Catskills. Matt's son was supposed to have come too, but has dropped out, leaving Sam alone with the two middle-aged men. At first, it all goes well: she puts up with their "banter and bickering", and simply rolls her eyes when it veers a bit too close to misogyny for her taste. But then comes the "incident": an "off-hand, off-colour" remark by Matt that leaves her visibly shaken, and sets in motion a devastating "domino effect of disappointments" when her father fails to come to her defence.
In this beautifully crafted film, Donaldson tenderly captures the experience of a teenage girl, said Aimee Ferrier in Far Out, while sharply exploring the fraught relationship between two insecure, disappointed men.
The Week
Escape your echo chamber. Get the facts behind the news, plus analysis from multiple perspectives.
Sign up for The Week's Free Newsletters
From our morning news briefing to a weekly Good News Newsletter, get the best of The Week delivered directly to your inbox.
From our morning news briefing to a weekly Good News Newsletter, get the best of The Week delivered directly to your inbox.
Nothing much happens, said Kevin Maher in The Times. The film is all "dramatic subtlety and delicate character arcs", yet it is "intensely compelling", and "somehow makes complete emotional sense". The main draw, however, is Collias, whose "wordless reaction shots are so full of careworn internal conflict... she effectively authors the mood of the movie".
A free daily email with the biggest news stories of the day – and the best features from TheWeek.com
-
‘No Other Choice,’ ‘Dead Man’s Wire,’ and ‘Father Mother Sister Brother’Feature A victim of downsizing turns murderous, an angry Indiana man takes a lender hostage, and a portrait of family by way of three awkward gatherings
-
Political cartoons for January 11Cartoons Sunday’s political cartoons include green energy, a simple plan, and more
-
The launch of the world’s first weight-loss pillSpeed Read Novo Nordisk and Eli Lilly have been racing to release the first GLP-1 pill
-
Film reviews: ‘No Other Choice,’ ‘Dead Man’s Wire,’ and ‘Father Mother Sister Brother’Feature A victim of downsizing turns murderous, an angry Indiana man takes a lender hostage, and a portrait of family by way of three awkward gatherings
-
Courgette and leek ijeh (Arabic frittata) recipeThe Week Recommends Soft leeks, tender courgette, and fragrant spices make a crisp frittata
-
Avatar: Fire and Ash – third instalment feels like ‘a relic of an earlier era’Talking Point Latest sequel in James Cameron’s passion project is even ‘more humourless’ than the last
-
The Zorg: meticulously researched book is likely to ‘become a classic’The Week Recommends Siddharth Kara’s harrowing account of the voyage that helped kick-start the anti-slavery movement
-
The Housemaid: an enjoyably ‘pulpy’ concoctionThe Week Recommends Formulaic psychological horror with Sydney Sweeney is ‘kind of a scream’
-
William Nicholson: a ‘rich and varied’ exhibitionThe Week Recommends The wide-ranging show brings together portraits, illustrations, prints and posters, alongside ‘ravishing’ still lifes
-
Oh, Mary! – an ‘irreverent, counter-historical’ delightThe Week Recommends Mason Alexander Park ‘gives the funniest performance in town’ as former First Lady Mary Todd Lincoln
-
The ultimate films of 2025 by genreThe Week Recommends From comedies to thrillers, documentaries to animations, 2025 featured some unforgettable film moments