Garsington Opera opens its summer festival with two 'very different productions'
A 'fabulous' new staging of Tchaikovsky's The Queen of Spades and Donizetti's fake-love-potion comedy L'elisir d'amore

Since 2011, when it left its original home following the death of its founder Leonard Ingrams, Garsington Opera has been based on the Getty estate at Wormsley in Buckinghamshire, said Richard Fairman in the Financial Times. "Nestled in the Chiltern Hills, with formal gardens and a full-scale cricket pitch, it has proved the ideal venue for an upmarket summer opera festival." And the festival now has the feeling of a serious operation, firing on all cylinders. Garsington Studios, its new cultural hub, is up and running (a winter season of concerts is soon to be announced). Productions of Handel's "Rodelinda" and Beethoven's "Fidelio" are in rehearsal. And the festival has opened with two similarly impressive but very different productions – the one brooding and darkly heightened; the other charming and sunny.
Director Jack Furness's superb production of Tchaikovsky's "The Queen of Spades", based on Pushkin's short story, affirms it as the composer's "most substantial and forward-looking operatic achievement", said Martin Kettle in The Guardian. He has retained its 18th century setting, but in every other respect this is an "unmistakably dark 21st century reading" – and an "overwhelmingly convincing staging". Irish tenor Aaron Cawley is a prodigiously intense, "Heathcliffian" Hermann, while Laura Wilde is a "haunted and haunting" Lisa. Although excellently sung, both performances would benefit from more dramatic heft, said Ivan Hewett in The Daily Telegraph. Nevertheless, this is a "fabulous new production", elevated by the Philharmonia Orchestra under Douglas Boyd – and by Garsington's lavish and "breathtakingly vigorous" 32-strong chorus.
The other season opener is a light and fizzing production of Donizetti's fake-love-potion comedy "L'elisir d'amore", said George Hall in The Stage. Director Christopher Luscombe has set the action in a hilltop town in southern Italy in 1944, its piazza "triumphantly conjured by Simon Higlett's hyper-realistic set". Luscombe and a "uniformly excellent cast understand that while comedy provides the surface appeal of Donizetti's enduring piece, not far beneath lies an essential pathos" – and it makes for a "perfect summer evening's entertainment, with real heart amid the laughs". All four leads are terrific, but Oleksiy Palchykov, as Nemorino, is a "vocal phenomenon" who stops the show with his stunning account of the famous aria Una furtiva lagrima.
Subscribe to The Week
Escape your echo chamber. Get the facts behind the news, plus analysis from multiple perspectives.

Sign up for The Week's Free Newsletters
From our morning news briefing to a weekly Good News Newsletter, get the best of The Week delivered directly to your inbox.
From our morning news briefing to a weekly Good News Newsletter, get the best of The Week delivered directly to your inbox.
The production benefits from some "delightful character interactions" and Luscombe's detailed direction, said Mark Pullinger in The Times. And under Chloe Rooke's baton, Donizetti's score fizzes "like chilled prosecco. Perfect fare for those summer picnics."
Sign up for Today's Best Articles in your inbox
A free daily email with the biggest news stories of the day – and the best features from TheWeek.com
-
The Rehearsal series two: Nathan Fielder's docu-comedy is 'laugh-out-loud funny'
The Week Recommends Television's 'great illusionist' has turned his attention to commercial airline safety
-
The Ballad of Wallis Island: bittersweet British comedy is a 'delight'
The Week Recommends A reclusive millionaire lures his favourite folk duo to an island for an 'awkward reunion'
-
Aston Martin Vantage Roadster: 'a rare treat indeed'
The Week Recommends The Roadster version of Aston Martin's new Vantage coupé makes even 'the most mundane journey feel special'
-
The Rehearsal series two: Nathan Fielder's docu-comedy is 'laugh-out-loud funny'
The Week Recommends Television's 'great illusionist' has turned his attention to commercial airline safety
-
The Ballad of Wallis Island: bittersweet British comedy is a 'delight'
The Week Recommends A reclusive millionaire lures his favourite folk duo to an island for an 'awkward reunion'
-
Aston Martin Vantage Roadster: 'a rare treat indeed'
The Week Recommends The Roadster version of Aston Martin's new Vantage coupé makes even 'the most mundane journey feel special'
-
Bad Friend: Tiffany Watt Smith explores why women abandon friendships
The Week Recommends A 'deeply researched' account of female friendship through history
-
Film reviews: The Phoenician Scheme, Bring Her Back, and Jane Austen Wrecked My Life
Feature A despised mogul seeks a fresh triumph, orphaned siblings land with a nightmare foster mother, and a Jane fan finds herself in a love triangle
-
Music reviews: Tune-Yards and PinkPantheress
Feature "Better Dreaming" and "Fancy That"
-
Art review: Jeffrey Gibson: The Space in Which to Place Me
Feature The Broad, Los Angeles, through Sept. 28
-
Bryan Burrough's 6 favorite books about Old West gunfighters
Feature The Texas-raised author recommends works by T.J. Stiles, John Boessenecker, and more