DeSantis vs. Disney: Has the governor gone too far?

Florida Gov. Ron DeSantis (R) has been at war with the Walt Disney Company ever since the entertainment conglomerate criticized the governor's controversial so-called "Don't Say Gay" legislation. One year later, the governor initially claimed a huge win in his crusade, signing legislation that would have given him a wide swath of powers over the company's iconic Orlando theme park, Walt Disney World.

The bill, The Associated Press said, gave DeSantis control of the Reedy Creek Improvement District, which serves as the governing jurisdiction and tax district for the Walt Disney World Resort complex. The AP noted that the new law requires DeSantis to "appoint a five-member board to oversee the government services that the Disney district provides." Board members were previously named through Disney entities.

However, the Mouse House did not go quietly, as while DeSantis was enacting this new legislation, Disney quietly reached an agreement with its outgoing board members that stripped DeSantis' board of almost all power. Under these guidelines, DeSantis' handpicked members cannot do anything beyond maintaining the park's basic infrastructure. The company was not done taking action, though, as Disney also sued DeSantis, claiming his steps were a violation of Disney's First Amendment rights because the governor installed his handpicked board without permission. That case is ongoing, though DeSantis has taken steps to have it tossed and has also brought a lawsuit of his own against Disney.

Subscribe to The Week

Escape your echo chamber. Get the facts behind the news, plus analysis from multiple perspectives.

SUBSCRIBE & SAVE

Sign up for The Week's Free Newsletters

From our morning news briefing to a weekly Good News Newsletter, get the best of The Week delivered directly to your inbox.

From our morning news briefing to a weekly Good News Newsletter, get the best of The Week delivered directly to your inbox.

Sign up

Disney has also canceled a $1 billion investment project in Florida that would have brought 2,000 jobs to the Orlando area, the Pensacola News Journal reported. The outlet described the decision as "a major blow to Central Florida's economy."

What are commentators saying?

President Biden previously criticized DeSantis' initial attempts to take control of Disney, saying the efforts are evidence that the "far right has taken over the [Republican] party." And even some Republicans think DeSantis has gone too far, and even former Vice President Mike Pence told CNBC that the governor's actions are "beyond the scope of what I as a conservative, limited-government Republican would be prepared to do."

But the initial legislation actually wasn't as far-reaching as DeSantis had initially hoped, The Financial Times wrote. It "fell far short of his original goal" of dissolving the district entirely, and instead amounts to little more than a name change. But he did "secure a significant victory" in his new-found power to appoint the district's entire board of directors. He has already "packed the board with political allies," and they could weaponize their power to approve infrastructure projects as "leverage" over the company if they are allowed to maintain control.

The governor's plan seems to go against typical Republicanism, legal expert and MSNBC commentator Tristian Snell suggested. "For almost 100 years, the right aimed to give companies more rights — including on speech," Snell wrote on Twitter. "DeSantis is undoing all that."

What's next for Disney?

Disney originally pledged to abide by the new rules, even as it was crafting a workaround from DeSantis. In a statement obtained by Variety, the company said it was "ready to work within this new framework," adding that it would not try to challenge Florida's laws in court. However, even as this statement was being released, it is clear that Disney was working behind the scenes to sue the governor for his actions.

Despite the legal jostling, Disney told CNN that it was holding steadfast, and that all previous agreements with the state "were appropriate, and were discussed and approved in open, noticed public forums in compliance with Florida's Government in the Sunshine law." So it seems that the fight between Disney and DeSantis may just be getting started.

May 22, 2023: This article has been updated to reflect new developments.