A decision to house more than 1,200 asylum seekers at a former military barracks in Oxfordshire is likely to face a legal challenge after planning permission was fast-tracked by Housing Secretary Angela Rayner. The nearby village of Piddington voted to leave the UK in a symbolic referendum in September, in protest at the plans. And its parish council chair, Tim McNally, said last week that ministers should “absolutely” be ready for a court battle.
Where to house asylum seekers and those who have arrived illegally in the UK while their applications are being processed remains one of the most contentious issues in British politics.
How many asylum seekers are in hotels? The number of asylum seekers housed in hotels, which were meant to be used as a temporary measure, rocketed after 2020, amid a dramatic increase in small boats crossing the Channel. These hotels often act as a lightning rod for anti-migrant protests. They are also disproportionately expensive, costing around six times more, on average, than other types of accommodation, according to The Migration Observatory.
Between 31 March 2023 and 31 March 2026, the proportion of asylum seekers housed in hotels halved, from 42% to 21%. The government has pledged to end the practice entirely by 2029.
What are the other options? Asylum seekers have also been placed in ordinary flats or houses in multiple occupation, including properties rented from private landlords or from social housing providers. But this puts “added pressure on already high rents in the private sector”, said Sky News, and leads to “angry accusations that migrants are being given homes ahead of UK citizens”.
Another option is to repurpose former military barracks. As of the first quarter of this year, 989 asylum seekers were housed in what the Home Office calls “large sites” such as ex-military facilities and waterborne vessels, said The Migration Observatory. Yet barracks are not necessarily a cheaper option than hotels, because of the cost of converting them for their new use.
They have also proven controversial, as in the Piddington case. Similar previous attempts have largely failed because “accommodating large numbers of people near small communities is difficult to manage”, said a 2025 report by the National Audit Office.
|