What happened The BBC has issued a formal apology to Donald Trump for an edited Panorama documentary that merged separate parts of his 6 January 2021 speech, creating what the corporation now concedes was a “mistaken impression” of a direct call to violence. The programme, broadcast ahead of last year’s US presidential election, will not be shown again.
Who said what In a letter to Trump’s legal team, the BBC said it “sincerely regrets the manner in which the video clip was edited”, but “strongly disagrees that there is a basis for a defamation claim”. BBC chair Samir Shah has also personally written to the White House to express regret. Trump’s lawyers have demanded a “full and fair retraction”, an apology and financial compensation, threatening a $1 billion lawsuit. Speaking to Fox News, the US president said his speech had been “butchered” and that viewers had been “defrauded”.
Trump has a history of legal action against news organisations, said Athena Stavrou in The Independent, having “filed lawsuits against media companies before, including The New York Times, The Wall Street Journal and CNN”. This is “the BBC v Trump, Farage and co”, said Marina Hyde in The Guardian. Not so, said The Telegraph’s editorial board. “There is no right-wing plot against the BBC”, rather “its troubles are of its own making”.
What next? The BBC argues that any legal action would face significant hurdles, including US protections for political speech and the limited distribution of the programme. It remains unclear whether Trump will proceed with a lawsuit. |