GCSE results day has come and gone, and for many, celebrations have begun. But the nearly 40% of students who have not received a passing grade of 4 or higher in their maths or English exams will be required to resit in November.
This "soul-destroying" policy may be well-intended, but "it looks to be utterly demoralising to pupils who find difficulty" with the tests, said Alan Smithers, director of the Centre for Education and Employment Research (CEER) at the University of Buckingham.
Subscribe to The Week
Escape your echo chamber. Get the facts behind the news, plus analysis from multiple perspectives.
Sign up for The Week's Free Newsletters
From our morning news briefing to a weekly Good News Newsletter, get the best of The Week delivered directly to your inbox.
From our morning news briefing to a weekly Good News Newsletter, get the best of The Week delivered directly to your inbox.
The data shows, too, that after the first mandatory resit, the treadmill continues: "Demoralisingly, barely one in five of those taking obligatory resits of maths and English GCSEs – a condition of funding for their post-16 education – achieved the necessary pass grade," wrote The Guardian's editorial board.
What did the commentators say?
A "hyper-fixation" on the proportion of pupils achieving the top grades "means we tend to overlook something much more important", said Kristina Murkett for The Spectator: "the long tail of underachievement in England".
The pass rate for resits is historically much lower than the first-time pass rate, and it fell again this year, dipping down to 20.9%. Given that, the "chances of success" for those resitting in November "are likely to be worse than before the pandemic" said The Guardian.
The "dismal" resit pass rate is proof that "you can't just keep testing people to success" said Murkett. "Students should be given the opportunity to retake if they wish," but it is "educational madness" to force struggling pupils to repeat the exam "over and over again and expect different results".
What next?
Labour's recent rise to power has prompted renewed cries for change, especially given the party's pledge to centre working-class children in education reform. The government has put post-16 qualifications under scrutiny, and a curriculum review is underway. According to the Financial Times, Education Secretary Bridget Phillipson is considering revising the resit policy. But according to Polly Toynbee in The Guardian, in some ways "it's all about to get much worse".
Starting this September, students who have not passed their exams must spend three hours per week on English and four on maths out of a total 15 hours allotted for post-16 study or their school will lose funding for their education. A marked increase, this doesn't leave much time for other interests, and may put students off education altogether, said Association of Colleges head David Hughes.
One potential solution comes from the AQA, an education charity and exam board who have "assembled experts of all kinds to plan an entirely new approach to exams and educate everyone in essential life skills", said Toynbee.
"The big idea is that everyone should take basic exams covering everyday numeracy, literacy and digital fluency: they just need to pass, no grade, no contest, like passing a driving test."
The exams will have to change drastically, and fast, to appease some experts who say they currently don't reflect life's most important skills or learnings. Smithers, the CEER director, says he "would suggest that they do not necessarily embody the grasp of words and numbers that is necessary to cope with life as it is lived".
-
Book reviews: 'King of Kings: The Iranian Revolution' and 'Gwyneth: The Biography'Feature How the Iranian Revolution began and Gwyneth Paltrow's life in the spotlight
-
Garrett Graff's 6 favorite books that shine new light on World War IIFeature The author recommends works by James D. Hornfischer, Craig L. Symonds, and more
-
5 fun cycling tours that let you vacation on two wheelsThe Week Recommends Gain a new perspective while pedaling
-
Education: America First vs. foreign studentsFeature Trump's war on Harvard escalates as he blocks foreign students from enrolling at the university
-
Where will international students go if not the US?Talking Points China, Canada and the UK are ready to educate the world
-
Colleges are canceling affinity graduations amid DEI attacks but students are pressing onIn the Spotlight The commencement at Harvard University was in the news, but other colleges are also taking action
-
Education: Can public schools be religious?Feature A Supreme Court seems ready to rule in favor of religious charter schools in Oklahoma, which could reshape public education
-
Supreme Court may bless church-run charter schoolsSpeed Read The case is 'one of the biggest on church and state in a generation'
-
The Department of Education is meant to 'advise and assist' US schoolsIn the Spotlight K-12 gets the attention. The money goes to higher ed.
-
Is academic freedom in peril?Today's Big Question Faculty punishments are on the rise
-
Anti-Israel protests impact a Jewish-rooted universityThe Explainer The president of Brandeis University resigned as a result of multiple factors, including his handling of recent protests
