MPs and their screens: should mobile phones be banned from the chamber?
Some would ‘do well to rethink their whole relationship to smartphones and social media’
If we want to ensure that Neil Parish is the last MP to watch porn in the Commons, there’s an easy way to do it, said Michael Deacon in The Daily Telegraph. Just ban mobile phones from the chamber. Politicians shouldn’t be using them there anyway. Over my years observing the chamber as a sketch writer, I increasingly saw “rows and rows of MPs gazing listlessly at their phones, like a vast roomful of bored teenagers”.
Such MPs are probably engaged in “perfectly innocent, even useful activities: replying to emails from constituents, or to WhatsApp messages from party whips”. But it’s rude and destroys the whole point of them being there. Asked in a 2016 interview why so many of his colleagues had been gawping at their screens while he delivered Labour’s response to an autumn statement, John McDonnell replied, “It doesn’t look good, but that’s what happens now”. Well, it shouldn’t.
There’s no justification for it, agreed Patrick Maguire in The Times. Given that Speakers have long forbidden MPs from reading newspapers in the chamber, it hardly makes sense that our representatives are allowed to sit there playing with their phones. Voters are entitled to “at least the appearance of concentration. As with justice, that scrutiny is seen to be done is as important as the scrutiny itself. Time to switch off.”
The Week
Escape your echo chamber. Get the facts behind the news, plus analysis from multiple perspectives.
Sign up for The Week's Free Newsletters
From our morning news briefing to a weekly Good News Newsletter, get the best of The Week delivered directly to your inbox.
From our morning news briefing to a weekly Good News Newsletter, get the best of The Week delivered directly to your inbox.
Indeed, MPs would do well to rethink their whole relationship to smartphones and social media, said Sebastian Payne in the FT. They’ve developed an unhealthy attachment to Twitter, treating it as a constant sounding board and source of ideas. This is a mistake, as it’s “phenomenally unrepresentative” of voters’ concerns. It’s a “self-selecting bubble” where angry partisanship and novelty trump reason, and where trending topics “come and go within hours”.
It was Twitter, typically, that convinced Labour MPs to nominate Jeremy Corbyn to contest the leadership to “widen the debate”. The party’s leadership is determined not to let the platform lead them astray again. As one influential member of the shadow cabinet put it: “All of us as MPs should spend less time on Twitter and spend more time knocking on doors in marginal seats.” Wise words.
A free daily email with the biggest news stories of the day – and the best features from TheWeek.com
-
Massacre in the favela: Rio’s police take on the gangsIn the Spotlight The ‘defence operation’ killed 132 suspected gang members, but could spark ‘more hatred and revenge’
-
The John Lewis ad: touching, or just weird?Talking Point This year’s festive offering is full of 1990s nostalgia – but are hedonistic raves really the spirit of Christmas?
-
Codeword: November 15, 2025The daily codeword puzzle from The Week
-
Massacre in the favela: Rio’s police take on the gangsIn the Spotlight The ‘defence operation’ killed 132 suspected gang members, but could spark ‘more hatred and revenge’
-
Obamacare: Why premiums are rocketingFeature The rise is largely due to the Dec. 31 expiration of pandemic-era ‘enhanced’ premium subsidies, which are at the heart of the government shutdown
-
The GOP: Will it welcome antisemites?Feature That Carlson would grant Fuentes access to his massive audience is proof that his hate ‘is entering the MAGA mainstream’
-
Trump’s trade war: has China won?Talking Point US president wanted to punish Beijing, but the Asian superpower now holds the whip hand
-
Democrats: Falling for flawed outsidersfeature Graham Platner’s Senate bid in Maine was interrupted by the resurfacing of his old, controversial social media posts
-
Trump’s White House ballroom: a threat to the republic?Talking Point Trump be far from the first US president to leave his mark on the Executive Mansion, but to critics his remodel is yet more overreach
-
Meet Ireland’s new socialist presidentIn the Spotlight Landslide victory of former barrister and ‘outsider’ Catherine Connolly could ‘mark a turning point’ in anti-establishment politics
-
Should TV adverts reflect the nation?Talking Point Reform MP Sarah Pochin’s controversial comments on black and Asian actors in adverts expose a real divide on race and representation