Sue Gray, once a senior but obscure government mandarin and now practically a household name, is set to release her report on rule-breaking Downing Street parties later today.
Having been tasked with investigating claims that No. 10 staff, including Boris Johnson, repeatedly broke Covid-19 restrictions, Gray – dubbed “Whitehall’s sleazebuster in chief” – now holds the fate of the prime minister “in her hands”, The Times said.
Publication of her long-awaited report into the debacle was held off until the conclusion of the Metropolitan Police’s Operation Hillman. The investigation has concluded, with 83 people – including Johnson, his wife Carrie, and Chancellor Rishi Sunak – given 126 fines for Covid breaches. Gray is now clear to release her report, which is thought to be highly critical of Johnson and his senior aides.
Subscribe to The Week
Escape your echo chamber. Get the facts behind the news, plus analysis from multiple perspectives.
The PM received only one fixed penalty notice from the Met Police. But new pictures obtained by ITV News, which show the prime minister raising a glass to Lee Cain, his outgoing director of communications, at a leaving party in November 2020, are likely to raise questions from unhappy backbench MPs in the week Gray’s report is slated for release.
A BBC Panorama documentary last night also painted a picture of packed parties and a culture set by Johnson for staff to be able to ��let their hair down”. One anonymous insider told the programme: “He wasn’t saying, ‘Can everyone break up and go home? Can everyone socially distance? Can everyone put masks on?’ No, he wasn’t telling anybody that. He was grabbing a glass for himself.”
‘Woman who runs Britain’
A permanent secretary in the Department for Levelling Up, Housing and Communities, her “formidable reputation” in Westminster was forged during her years as director-general of propriety and ethics in the Cabinet Office, a role she held from 2012 to 2018, according to the Financial Times (FT).
“Westminster is littered with major scalps” she took while in the role, including former deputy prime minister Damian Green, who quit after an inquiry led by Gray found he made “inaccurate and misleading” statements over what he knew about claims pornography was found on his office computer in 2008.
She also “had a hand” in the resignations of ex-chief whip Andrew Mitchell and former defence secretary Liam Fox, the paper added.
At the time, she was described by the then BBC Newsnight policy editor Chris Cook as the “most powerful civil servant you’ve never heard of”.
However, Cook also reported that Gray had previously advised special advisers to destroy emails by “double deletion” in an attempt to “thwart” Freedom of Information requests, which are frequently used by journalists when investigating public bodies.
A former adviser told Politico she was nicknamed “Sue Gray area” by those working on Whitehall because “everything she does is so murky”. “There’s never any paper trail. There’s never any record,” they added. “Her job is to make bad things go away for the prime minister however she can.”
Former cabinet minister Oliver Letwin once speculated that her influence made her perhaps as powerful as the prime minister, according to extracts of his diaries cited by the FT.
“It took me precisely two years before I realised who it is that runs Britain. Our great United Kingdom is actually entirely run by a lady called Sue Gray, the head of ethics or something in the Cabinet Office. Unless she agrees, things just don’t happen.”
Gray began her career as a civil servant in the 1970s, with roles in transport, health, and work and pensions.
She married Northern Irish country and western singer Bill Conlon, leaving the civil service to run a pub in County Down, an area close to the border with Ireland so dangerous it was nicknamed “Bandit Country”, according to The Times. “I loved it, loved it at the time, I’d never do it again,” she later told the BBC.
She was “lured back to London” to work in the Cabinet Office under Gordon Brown and Tony Blair, reported The Guardian. According to one former adviser to Blair, she was a “fixer”, someone “who worked in the shadows to vet potential peerages and smooth over problems”.
Under David Cameron, she was given another high-profile role after making “an impression on the new government on its first day in office in 2010”, according to former chancellor George Osborne.
“Thirty minutes after the Labour team had left, everyone was fawning at David Cameron,” the former chancellor tweeted in December. “Then someone spoke out: ‘I’m sorry PM but you can’t do that.’ ‘Who’s that?’ I asked. Sue Gray.”
In 2018 she unexpectedly left Whitehall for a new role as permanent secretary of Northern Ireland’s finance department. In 2020 she then applied to become head of Northern Ireland’s civil service, but told the BBC she failed to land the role because she was “too much of a challenger”.
What’s the latest?
Gray released a limited interim report in January that criticised “failures of leadership and judgement” by No. 10 and the Cabinet Office, but she was limited on what she could say by the ongoing police investigation.
With her full report set to be published imminently, in recent days allies of the prime minister have accused Gray of “playing politics and enjoying the limelight a little too much”. There has also been finger-pointing over who scheduled a meeting between Johnson and Gray to discuss procedures surrounding the publication of the report, said the Daily Mail.
No. 10 admitted that the meeting had been organised by a senior aide, reportedly after Johnson was “apoplectic” over a report in The Times suggesting that Gray would directly criticise him for the culture in No. 10 and his attendance at events. The paper said that her findings may be “so damning that it could leave Boris Johnson with no choice but to resign”.
Gray has reportedly contacted 30 individuals, including Johnson, who are either named or indirectly referred to in her report, in order to give them a right of reply before the report is published.
A report in The Sunday Times also suggested that Gray was “surprised” that Johnson was fined only once, for attending a party thrown for his 56th birthday. One source told the paper that Gray thought the birthday party was “the least egregious event she has looked into.”
Her apparent misgivings over the police findings suggest that “far from being over, Johnson’s partygate hangover has several more days to run”, said the paper.
Officials with knowledge of the lockdown parties inquiry told the FT that Gray is “acutely aware” of the political consequences of the findings of her inquiry – findings which could end Johnson’s career. “She has to tread very carefully, even by her standards,” one said.
Continue reading for free
We hope you're enjoying The Week's refreshingly open-minded journalism.
Subscribed to The Week? Register your account with the same email as your subscription.