Israel's high court rejects Netanyahu's judicial coup, but is the fight really over?
The prime minister and his right-wing allies are content to let a sense of wartime unity reign...for now
After months of massive protests that rocked much of Israeli society for the majority of the summer, Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu's deeply controversial judicial reform effort was struck down this week by the very court whose authority it was meant to curtail. The 8-7 ruling against the Netanyahu-backed law that severely limited the court's ability to consider legislation passed by the Israeli Knesset marks a decisive defeat for the prime minister and his allies who passed the bill in late July amid unprecedented civic and political opposition. It also comes as Israel nears its third month of war in Gaza, where more than 20,000 Palestinians — the majority believed to be civilians — have died from a combined aerial bombardment and ground offensive that has inflamed the region, and indeed much of the world as well.
In a statement released shortly after the ruling was announced, the Court described the now-annulled portion of the bill, known broadly as the "reasonableness law," as having risked "severe and unprecedented damage to the basic characteristics of the State of Israel as a democratic state." Israeli Justice Minister Yariv Levin, one of the law's chief architects, disagreed, blasting the court for "taking into their hands all the powers, which in a democratic regime are supposed to be divided in a balanced way" in a statement obtained by the Jerusalem Post. Levin also criticized the court for releasing their verdict while Israel continues fighting in Gaza, calling the timing the "opposite of the spirit of unity" expected during wartime.
What the commentators said
The ruling could push Israel into a "constitutional and political crisis," according to Axios, which envisioned a scenario in which a forceful response from Netanyahu and his allies could push former Defense Minister Benny Gantz, a centrist, to leave Netanyahu's emergency unity government. This, in turn, would "leave Israel with a radical right-wing government to make decisions about the war" that could jeopardize American support.
Subscribe to The Week
Escape your echo chamber. Get the facts behind the news, plus analysis from multiple perspectives.
Sign up for The Week's Free Newsletters
From our morning news briefing to a weekly Good News Newsletter, get the best of The Week delivered directly to your inbox.
From our morning news briefing to a weekly Good News Newsletter, get the best of The Week delivered directly to your inbox.
While Netanyahu and his allies may try again to push their overhaul of the judiciary, "in practice" the coup "died on Monday night, if it had not already died on October 7," according to Haaretz columnist Gidi Weitz, who lamented that the seven dissenting justices "did not rise to the challenge" of a unanimous decision against Netanyahu's effort, even if they "did not give it a stamp of kashrut either."
Significant as striking down the reasonableness clause may be, the "more consequential part of the ruling" was a 12-3 decision that affirmed the High Court could in extraordinary circumstances review and revoke elements of the country's Basic Laws, which operate similarly to a constitution, according to The New York Times. Weitz seemingly agreed, calling it the "truly dramatic significance" of Monday's ruling, which acts as a "stop sign" for the right-wing Knesset, should it persist in its "campaign of destruction and attempts to undermine the foundations of democracy."
What next?
The Netanyahu government has worked to "downplay their loss" by "appealing again to wartime unity," The New York Times reported. The timing of the ruling ultimately may help Netanyahu, because "he can justify a lack of reaction, and after the war he will have more pressing matters," Israeli political columnist Amit Segal told the paper. Meanwhile, Netanyahu's allies have been quick to lob allegations that the court had violated some sense of wartime detente, with Science, Technology, and Innovation Minister Ofir Akunis calling it a "disgrace" and Knesset Speaker Amir Ohana, a member of Netanyahu's right-wing Likud party, lamenting that "we cannot engage in this as long as the war is in progress."
If the Netanyahu government's leaders attempt to restart their judicial battle, then "they have learned nothing," Yair Lapid, who heads the centrist Yesh Atid opposition party, warned on X, formerly Twitter, adding that they "haven't learned anything from October 7" either.
Netanyahu is facing intense criticism from Israelis for his handling of the ongoing war in Gaza, even as he has pledged to begin withdrawing troops from the region. A poll from the Israel Democracy Institute released on Tuesday shows just 15 percent of the country wants him to remain prime minister after the war concludes.
Create an account with the same email registered to your subscription to unlock access.
Sign up for Today's Best Articles in your inbox
A free daily email with the biggest news stories of the day – and the best features from TheWeek.com
Rafi Schwartz has worked as a politics writer at The Week since 2022, where he covers elections, Congress and the White House. He was previously a contributing writer with Mic focusing largely on politics, a senior writer with Splinter News, a staff writer for Fusion's news lab, and the managing editor of Heeb Magazine, a Jewish life and culture publication. Rafi's work has appeared in Rolling Stone, GOOD and The Forward, among others.
-
5 high-caliber cartoons about Kristi Noem shooting her puppy
Cartoons Artists take on the rainbow bridge, a farm upstate, and more
By The Week US Published
-
The Week Unwrapped: Why is the world running low on blood?
Podcast Scientists believe universal donor blood is within reach – plus, the row over an immersive D-Day simulation, and an Ozempic faux pas
By The Week Staff Published
-
Rishi Sunak's asylum spat with Ireland explained
In Depth Irish government plans to override court ruling that the UK is unsafe for asylum seekers
By The Week UK Published
-
'A financial windfall for Iranian terrorism'
Instant Opinion Opinion, comment and editorials of the day
By Harold Maass, The Week US Published
-
Xi comes to Europe: what's on the agenda?
The Explainer China's president visiting for first time since 2019, with spotlight on support for Russia over Ukraine and trade tensions with EU
By Harriet Marsden, The Week UK Published
-
'Box Trump in for real if he pulls another stunt. Put him behind bars.'
Instant Opinion Opinion, comment and editorials of the day
By Harold Maass, The Week US Published
-
US, Saudis near security deal, with or without Israel
Speed Read The historic pact would offer the Saudis security guarantees and could reshape the Middle East
By Peter Weber, The Week US Published
-
'Making a police state out of the liberal university'
Instant Opinion Opinion, comment and editorials of the day
By Harold Maass, The Week US Published
-
'Can we — the people who have bought so much already — really keep buying more?'
Instant Opinion Opinion, comment and editorials of the day
By Harold Maass, The Week US Published
-
Columbia begins suspending Gaza war protesters
Speed Read The students are potentially barred from campus buildings and finals and ineligible to graduate in May
By Peter Weber, The Week US Published
-
Summer Lee, the Pennsylvania 'squad' member who beat back a primary challenge
In the Spotlight Lee is the first Black woman ever elected to Congress from the Keystone State
By Justin Klawans, The Week US Published