House passes controversial change in how deficit effects of legislation get scored


On Tuesday, House Republicans passed a rule change instructing the Congressional Budget Office (CBO) to begin including "dynamic scoring" in its toolkit of methods for assessing legislation. The agency generally relies on "static scoring" to project the economic and budget effects of proposed policy changes — i.e. if a tax cut will reduce revenue by a certain amount, CBO simply projects deficits will increase by that amount and leaves it at that. Dynamic scoring attempts to include boosts to economic activity from the tax cut, which could create new tax revenue, offsetting at least some of the revenue loss in the static projection.
CBO's scoring currently includes small-scale behavioral responses to policy changes, like how individual workers and businesses may react. But how all those responses add up at the macroeconomic level — i.e. the economy as a whole, which is where budget effects play out — is the subject of massive debate among economists and policymakers. Everyone disagrees on how big the dynamic effect is, and how it might apply to different policies. So CBO has avoided using it.
Republicans are defending the change as a more "realistic" approach to policy, while critics contend it's a gambit to disguise budget-busting tax cuts. (Though as Joel Dodge pointed out at The Week, the spending programs often favored by Democrats could also get a leg up under dynamic scoring.) Finally, exactly how CBO will use dynamic scoring will be heavily influenced by the new head of the agency, whom House Republicans will pick in the coming weeks.
The Week
Escape your echo chamber. Get the facts behind the news, plus analysis from multiple perspectives.

Sign up for The Week's Free Newsletters
From our morning news briefing to a weekly Good News Newsletter, get the best of The Week delivered directly to your inbox.
From our morning news briefing to a weekly Good News Newsletter, get the best of The Week delivered directly to your inbox.
A free daily email with the biggest news stories of the day – and the best features from TheWeek.com
Jeff Spross was the economics and business correspondent at TheWeek.com. He was previously a reporter at ThinkProgress.
-
Nepal chooses toddler as its new ‘living goddess’
Under the Radar Girls between two and four are typically chosen to live inside the temple as the Kumari – until puberty strikes
-
October 5 editorial cartoons
Cartoons Sunday's political cartoons include half-truth hucksters, Capitol lockdown, and more
-
Jaguar Land Rover’s cyber bailout
Talking Point Should the government do more to protect business from the ‘cyber shockwave’?
-
Museum head ousted after Trump sword gift denial
Speed Read Todd Arrington, who led the Dwight D. Eisenhower Presidential Library and Museum, denied the Trump administration a sword from the collection as a gift for King Charles
-
Trump declares ‘armed conflict’ with drug cartels
speed read This provides a legal justification for recent lethal military strikes on three alleged drug trafficking boats
-
Supreme Court rules for Fed’s Cook in Trump feud
Speed Read Federal Reserve Governor Lisa Cook can remain in her role following Trump’s attempts to oust her
-
Judge rules Trump illegally targeted Gaza protesters
Speed Read The Trump administration’s push to arrest and deport international students for supporting Palestine is deemed illegal
-
Trump: US cities should be military ‘training grounds’
Speed Read In a hastily assembled summit, Trump said he wants the military to fight the ‘enemy within’ the US
-
US government shuts down amid health care standoff
Speed Read Democrats said they won’t vote for a deal that doesn’t renew Affordable Care Act health care subsidies
-
YouTube to pay Trump $22M over Jan. 6 expulsion
Speed Read The president accused the company of censorship following the suspension of accounts post-Capitol riot
-
Oregon sues to stop Trump military deployment
Speed Read The president wants to send the National Guard into Portland