Labour is facing allegations of cronyism after appointing several of its backers to prominent civil service roles.
Ian Corfield, a former banker who has donated over £20,000 to Labour politicians, was appointed to a Treasury post after the Civil Service Commission approved an "exception" to the usual requirement of fair and open competition for the role. Corfield has since stepped down and become a temporary, unpaid Treasury adviser.
Jess Sargeant, a former employee of the Labour Together think tank, was appointed deputy director in the Cabinet Office's propriety and constitution unit. And Emily Middleton, a former consultant seconded to Labour during its opposition days, has been appointed as a director general in the Department for Science, Innovation and Technology.
What did the commentators say? Labour's method of "bending the civil service to its will" has left it "vulnerable to accusations of cronyism", said The Times in a leading article. "The civil service – too often bloated and sclerotic – would benefit from more external expertise", but these appointments were "imposed on departments by fiat". Voters deserve more than a "chumocracy by stealth".
It's "striking" that many in the party seem surprised, "and in some cases slightly offended", by the backlash, said Katy Balls in The Spectator. Harriet Harman played down Corfield's donations as "a small amount of money for him", but it's "hard to see Harman making that defence had it been a Tory donor being given an appointment", said Balls.
As opposition leader, Starmer frequently criticised "Tory sleaze", and the recent controversies could lead to accusations of hypocrisy, warned Sir Alistair Graham, a former chairman of the Committee on Standards in Public Life, speaking to the i news site. "The danger for this government is that people might say they're no different to the last lot," he said.
What next? Addressing reporters after making a major speech today, the prime minister dismissed allegations of cronyism, telling reporters he wanted "honesty and integrity" in his government, and "the right people in the right places".
He added: "Most of these allegations and accusations are coming from the very people that dragged our country down in the first place." |