THE HOUSE where Ariel Castro allegedly held three women captive for a decade before their release on Monday is listed on the Trulia real estate website with an estimated value of $77,000 – more than double the house's worth a year ago. A 2012 valuation put it at $36,100 and that was with an intact front door.
2207 Seymour Avenue, where Amanda Berry, Gina DeJesus and Michelle Knight were kept sometimes bound by ropes and chains, is described as a Colonial-style 'single family home' located in the Tremont district of Cleveland, Ohio. According to the site, the average list price for similar homes is $125,717.
The Week
Escape your echo chamber. Get the facts behind the news, plus analysis from multiple perspectives.
Sign up for The Week's Free Newsletters
From our morning news briefing to a weekly Good News Newsletter, get the best of The Week delivered directly to your inbox.
From our morning news briefing to a weekly Good News Newsletter, get the best of The Week delivered directly to your inbox.
As for the detached garage, police have told the local media that the only times the women saw daylight during their long years in captivity was on two separate visits there. On both occasions, they were apparently dressed in wigs and disguises.
The Trulia site offers valuations of houses across the United States based on recent sale prices or – as in the case of Castro’s home – public records.
But will the real estate agents who advertise on Trulia ever get the chance to sell 2207 Seymour Avenue – and, if so, could they really hope to fetch $77,000 or thereabouts? One agent approached by The Week said the old valuation of $36,100 was nearer the mark for this area of Cleveland, given local crime statistics and the fact that many neighbouring properties are rundown.
There’s also the issue of unpaid taxes. According to USA Today, the city of Cleveland had already threatened to foreclose – or repossess – the house because Castro owes $2,501 in unpaid taxes so it’s likely the future of the house will be in the city’s hands.
Another local real estate agent told The Week that, given its relative low value and its miserable history, the house will most likely be bulldozed once Castro’s trial is over.
2207 Seymour Avenue is the house partly hidden behind the tree in the Trulia listing below.
-
Millet: Life on the Land – an 'absorbing' exhibitionThe Week Recommends Free exhibition at the National Gallery showcases the French artist's moving paintings of rural life
-
Scientists are speeding up evolutionUnder the radar Proteins can evolve in minutes
-
Crossword: August 29, 2025The Week's daily crossword
-
Cleveland kidnap victims thank supporters - videoIn Depth Amanda Berry, Gina DeJesus and Michelle Knight thank public for support after going to 'hell and back'
-
Ariel Castro is 'not monster' and will plead innocentSpeed Read Man accused of imprisoning three women in Ohio house is not guilty of kidnap and rape, says lawyer
-
Ariel Castro's fate: electric chair or an endless prison term?
In Depth Phillip Garrido's prison term was 431 years – and there was only one victim, Jaycee Lee Dugard, in his case
-
Raped, bound, chained: 10-year ordeal imposed by Ariel CastroIn Depth Ariel Castro faces court alone – his brothers played no part in the horrors at 2207 Seymour Avenue
-
Were Cleveland women raped after they were kidnapped?In Depth Reports emerge of multiple pregnancies at house on Seymour Avenue; Castro beat his wife after divorce
-
Kidnapped Amanda Berry's call to 911 operator – videoIn Depth 'I'm here. I'm free now,' says Cleveland kidnap victim but emergency dispatcher is slow to react
-
Cleveland kidnapping: why did it take a decade to find them?In Depth Questions raised by discovery of three young women kept hostage inside a house in Ohio for ten years
