Democrats are overplaying their hand on unions
The connection between unions and the middle class is not as straightforward as progressives claim
The controversy surrounding Scott Walker's views (or non-views) on President Obama's patriotism and religious faith have only increased the Wisconsin governor's stature and visibility on the right. And that's probably just fine with many Democrats.
Should Walker win the GOP presidential nod, progressives will surely try to turn him into a symbol of all that's gone wrong with the U.S. economy. Why wouldn't they? If you believe that the decades-long decline of union power is what's been crippling the American middle class, then a union-busting governor makes a perfect foil in 2016. Maybe even better than a job-slashing, private equity investor and banker did in 2012. And indeed, progressives love to tout the connection between unions' decline and middle-class woes. "Middle-class decline mirrors the fall of unions in one chart," garbles The Huffington Post. "Why screwing unions screws the entire middle class," seethes Mother Jones. "Without unions, the middle class withers," claims the Center for American Progress.
Whatever the political smarts of this approach, the underlying economic theory — while popular on the Elizabeth Warren left — isn't as crystal clear as progressives claim. Yet the idea that the slow death of unions also killed the middle class still gets repeated over and over. Here is Lawrence Mishel, president of the progressive Economic Policy Institute, earlier this week in a New York Times op-ed:
Subscribe to The Week
Escape your echo chamber. Get the facts behind the news, plus analysis from multiple perspectives.
Sign up for The Week's Free Newsletters
From our morning news briefing to a weekly Good News Newsletter, get the best of The Week delivered directly to your inbox.
From our morning news briefing to a weekly Good News Newsletter, get the best of The Week delivered directly to your inbox.
Shorter version: Since it's become harder for workers to unionize, union membership has declined, and the bosses have increased their share of the corporate spoils.
That's a strong claim. But it's something of an outlier view among economists. Last year, the University of Chicago's graduate business school asked top economists if they agreed with this statement: "Information technology and automation are a central reason why median wages have been stagnant in the U.S. over the past decade, despite rising productivity." A strong plurality, 43 percent, agreed. Only 28 percent blamed a variety of other causes, including trade, the financial crisis, weak education, and yes, the decline in unionization. (If you think the deck was stacked with right-wing economists, consider that left-wing economist and New York Times columnist Paul Krugman has explained the effect of unions on the income gap to be "significant," but "secondary" to technological change.)
Inequality and wage stagnation are problems witnessed across advanced economies. Wages haven't been going up in Canada either, even though the share of the workforce in unions is twice that of America's and holding steady, according to the OECD. An international macro story requires an international macro explanation — like technology, manifested as automation (computerization eliminating "routine" jobs such as assembly line workers and receptionists) and globalization, itself enabled by the IT revolution.
Indeed, the apparent connection between falling unionization and rising income inequality may itself be the result of how "computerization ... and globalization may a have fostered a more dynamic, and unequal, American capitalism to which unions were poorly adapted," according to a 2011 paper out of Harvard and the University of Washington. Even inequality guru Thomas Piketty concedes that "the main policy to reduce inequality is not progressive taxation, is not the minimum wage. It's really education. It's really investing in skills, investing in schools."
If you can't diagnose the problem, you can't come up with an effective remedy. And suggesting that the fall of unions is the biggest factor of middle-class stagnation is a misdiagnosis of our problem.
Many economists would say deunionization matters somewhat. It's just not the everything explanation that Democrats wish it were.
Create an account with the same email registered to your subscription to unlock access.
Sign up for Today's Best Articles in your inbox
A free daily email with the biggest news stories of the day – and the best features from TheWeek.com
James Pethokoukis is the DeWitt Wallace Fellow at the American Enterprise Institute where he runs the AEIdeas blog. He has also written for The New York Times, National Review, Commentary, The Weekly Standard, and other places.
-
Why au pairs might become a thing of the past
Under The Radar Brexit and wage ruling are threatening the 'mutually beneficial arrangement'
By Chas Newkey-Burden, The Week UK Published
-
'A direct, protracted war with Israel is not something Iran is equipped to fight'
Instant Opinion Opinion, comment and editorials of the day
By Harold Maass, The Week US Published
-
Today's political cartoons - April 17, 2024
Cartoons Wednesday's cartoons - political anxiety, jury sorting hat, and more
By The Week US Published
-
Arizona court reinstates 1864 abortion ban
Speed Read The law makes all abortions illegal in the state except to save the mother's life
By Rafi Schwartz, The Week US Published
-
Trump, billions richer, is selling Bibles
Speed Read The former president is hawking a $60 "God Bless the USA Bible"
By Peter Weber, The Week US Published
-
The debate about Biden's age and mental fitness
In Depth Some critics argue Biden is too old to run again. Does the argument have merit?
By Grayson Quay Published
-
How would a second Trump presidency affect Britain?
Today's Big Question Re-election of Republican frontrunner could threaten UK security, warns former head of secret service
By Harriet Marsden, The Week UK Published
-
'Rwanda plan is less a deterrent and more a bluff'
Instant Opinion Opinion, comment and editorials of the day
By The Week UK Published
-
Henry Kissinger dies aged 100: a complicated legacy?
Talking Point Top US diplomat and Nobel Peace Prize winner remembered as both foreign policy genius and war criminal
By Harriet Marsden, The Week UK Last updated
-
Trump’s rhetoric: a shift to 'straight-up Nazi talk'
Why everyone's talking about Would-be president's sinister language is backed by an incendiary policy agenda, say commentators
By The Week UK Published
-
More covfefe: is the world ready for a second Donald Trump presidency?
Today's Big Question Republican's re-election would be a 'nightmare' scenario for Europe, Ukraine and the West
By Sorcha Bradley, The Week UK Published