THE ARGUMENTS FOR
Child labour is an absolute necessity for the survival of millions of people in many of the poorest parts of the world. Western ideas of what is acceptable are completely at odds with the grim reality of life in the slums of Asia and Africa.
The notion that child workers are being deprived of a 'normal' childhood is misguided. Except for Europe during the last century, child labour has been part of normal life in almost every society in history.
The Week
Escape your echo chamber. Get the facts behind the news, plus analysis from multiple perspectives.
Sign up for The Week's Free Newsletters
From our morning news briefing to a weekly Good News Newsletter, get the best of The Week delivered directly to your inbox.
From our morning news briefing to a weekly Good News Newsletter, get the best of The Week delivered directly to your inbox.
Child labour need not necessarily mean sweatshops. In developing countries many family-run businesses, such as restaurants, employ their own children to help out and learn practical skills.
Jobs provided by Western clothing companies are relatively safe compared to the alternatives. When US Congress banned imports of cheap clothing from Bangladesh in 1999, 50,000 children were forced to take jobs in brick factories or become prostitutes.
In some parts of the developing world, such as Brazil, the authorities accept that child labour is unavoidable. They can then put in plans to provide special financial support for families of working children, so that they can also attend school.
THE ARGUMENTS AGAINST
Child labour of the kind used by the clothing industry is immoral on the most basic level. For the benefit of Western consumers poor children are being exploited and denied a chance to enjoy their lives.
Businesses which employ children illegally are not bound by any laws. It is not unusual for children to work 16 to 19 hours a day.
Children can more easily be exploited than adults in the workplace.
Cramped, harmful conditions can stunt a child's growth and ruin their health. In some cases toxic fumes result in lung damage and an early death; in others having to focus on tiny intricate work (such as embroidery) can ruin their eyesight.
Low wages paid to children have a detrimental effect on wages paid to adults. Trade unions argue that employers can hold adult workers to ransom if their jobs can be taken by children at any time.
Despite government incentives to keep working children in school, children with jobs will be too exhausted to properly benefit from their classes.
-
'A symbol of the faceless corporate desire'Instant Opinion Opinion, comment and editorials of the day
-
Say farewell to summer at these underrated US lakesThe Week Recommends Have one last blast
-
Truck drivers are questioning the Trump administration's English mandateTalking Points Some have praised the rules, others are concerned they could lead to profiling
-
Home Office worker accused of spiking mistress’s drink with abortion drugSpeed Read Darren Burke had failed to convince his girlfriend to terminate pregnancy
-
In hock to Moscow: exploring Germany’s woeful energy policySpeed Read Don’t expect Berlin to wean itself off Russian gas any time soon
-
Were Covid restrictions dropped too soon?Speed Read ‘Living with Covid’ is already proving problematic – just look at the travel chaos this week
-
Inclusive Britain: a new strategy for tackling racism in the UKSpeed Read Government has revealed action plan setting out 74 steps that ministers will take
-
Sandy Hook families vs. Remington: a small victory over the gunmakersSpeed Read Last week the families settled a lawsuit for $73m against the manufacturer
-
Farmers vs. walkers: the battle over ‘Britain’s green and pleasant land’Speed Read Updated Countryside Code tells farmers: ‘be nice, say hello, share the space’
-
Motherhood: why are we putting it off?Speed Read Stats show around 50% of women in England and Wales now don’t have children by 30
-
Anti-Semitism in America: a case of double standards?Speed Read Officials were strikingly reluctant to link Texas synagogue attack to anti-Semitism
