Paxton & Whitfield's top tips for a Christmas cheeseboard
Hero Hirsh, manager of the cheesemonger's Jermyn Street flagship, serves up suggestions for a festive homage to fromage
When putting together a cheeseboard, you need to keep in mind the occasion. If it's for a buffet, for example, you might want to include lots of different styles of cheese for an indulgent offer. When it's part of a meal, however, I think people tend to get carried away with too many options. I personally like to go for three or four – more than that and you risk it being confusing on the palate. It also means you can buy generous-looking chunks of good cheeses instead of spindly pieces of nine or ten.
Generally, we recommend allowing 4oz per person, but the serving size is increased for Christmas; it's an occasion where people tend to go back to the cheeseboard after several hours and have another go. You probably want to up the portion size to 6oz, or even 8oz if you want leftovers as it's such as easy meal to have on Boxing Day and, of course, it doesn't involve any more cooking.
It's good to have a choice of styles – a soft and a hard cheese, a washed rind or a goat's cheese – to create a mixture of milks and textures. And if you have a blue cheese, the classic option is, of course, Stilton and it's important to get a really good one – we do a lovely Cropwell Bishop. The version you buy at supermarkets has often spent a lot of its life at very cold temperatures, but if you go to a proper cheesemonger you can have it cut from a whole cheese, knowing it's been looked after rather than frozen and wrapped in plastic. If you don't want Stilton, our Cote Hill Blue is a softer style from Lincolnshire and has an almost brie-like quality, so ticks two boxes on your cheeseboard.
The Week
Escape your echo chamber. Get the facts behind the news, plus analysis from multiple perspectives.
Sign up for The Week's Free Newsletters
From our morning news briefing to a weekly Good News Newsletter, get the best of The Week delivered directly to your inbox.
From our morning news briefing to a weekly Good News Newsletter, get the best of The Week delivered directly to your inbox.
It can be tricky to find accompaniments that work with all styles, so it's best to opt for something fruity and not too sweet or vinegary. Quince paste works well because it has a purity of fruit to it, and anything with figs is also very versatile. It's good to have a selection of crackers so you can mix and match according to the cheese.
In terms of drinks to serve with your cheeseboard, I personally love tawny port. It's not something I have all year round so it's a real festive treat. It complements lots of different types of cheeses, so you can have it with a triple cream such as a Brillat Savarin or with Gruyere, cheddars and much more.
HERO HIRSH is the manager of Paxton & Whitfield’s flagship shop on Jermyn Street, Piccadilly, London; paxtonandwhitfield.co.uk
A free daily email with the biggest news stories of the day – and the best features from TheWeek.com
-
The Week’s big New Year’s Day quiz 2026Quiz of the Year How much do you remember about 2025’s headlines? Put yourself to the test with our bumper quiz of the year
-
Is tanking ruining sports?Today's Big Question The NBA and the NFL want teams to compete to win. What happens if they decide not to?
-
‘Netflix needs to not just swallow HBO but also emulate it’instant opinion Opinion, comment and editorials of the day
-
How to make the most of chestnutsThe Week Recommends These versatile nuts have way more to offer than Nat King Cole ever let on
-
A Christmas Carol (or two)The Week Recommends These are the most delightful retellings of the Dickens classic from around the country
-
How weight-loss jabs are changing the way we eatIn The Spotlight Anti-obesity drugs have been a boon for Babybel but are supermarkets ready for a slimmed-down Christmas?
-
Oh yes they are! The UK’s best Christmas pantosThe Week Recommends Dive into the festive cheer, even into the new year, with some traditional favourites and modern twists
-
11 extra-special holiday gifts for everyone on your listThe Week Recommends Jingle their bells with the right present
-
May your loved ones eat, drink and be merry with these 9 edible Christmas giftsThe Week Recommends Let them eat babka (and cheese and licorice)
-
Best panettones for Christmas 2025: tried and tastedThe Week Recommends Festive, fluffy and full of joy, these panettones provide magic in every bite
-
Classic mince pies for the festive seasonThe Week Recommends The countdown to Christmas, and all its edible treats, has begun