Alexis Sanchez: Should Arsenal handball goal have stood?
Former referees divided over Mark Clattenburg's decision to award Gunners' first goal against Hull
Arsenal returned to winning ways on Saturday, relieving some of the pressure on their manager Arsene Wenger. But their first goal in the 2-0 over Hull was controversial as Alexis Sanchez clearly handled the ball in the act of scoring.
The Chilean's initial shot ricocheted off Tigers' keeper Eldin Jakupovic and up onto his right hand before it crossed the line. Referee Mark Clattenburg consulted with his assistant before awarding the goal and the moment was key to the outcome.
The goal came at a crucial time, reports Sam Morshead of MailOnline. "With the game locked at 0-0 and half-time approaching, and with Hull having enjoyed a fair number of chances in the Gunners' penalty area, the grumbles were growing louder inside the Emirates."
Subscribe to The Week
Escape your echo chamber. Get the facts behind the news, plus analysis from multiple perspectives.
Sign up for The Week's Free Newsletters
From our morning news briefing to a weekly Good News Newsletter, get the best of The Week delivered directly to your inbox.
From our morning news briefing to a weekly Good News Newsletter, get the best of The Week delivered directly to your inbox.
It amounted to "a great big dollop" of good fortune, says Morshead, that has divided pundits and even referees. It was even reported that the referee apologised to Hull players at half time.
But former World Cup final referee Howard Webb believes he was right to award the goal.
"It was not deliberate handball," he writes in The Times. "His hand was not in an unnatural position. When you kick a ball with your left foot your right arm comes out. The ball rebounded straight back and hit Sanchez's arm... there was no movement of the arm to the ball.
"I would argue that even if a defender had been hit on the line on the hand in a similar position after the ball had ricocheted back as they tried to kick it away, then it should not have been a penalty or a red card."
However, he accepts that other referees may not agree. One of those is Keith Hackett, another former ref writing in the Daily Telegraph. He says: "I thought it was a clear handball and should have been disallowed."
He sees the incident very differently to Webb and believes it was deliberate. "Sanchez's hand moves towards the ball. His left foot was moving forward and it would be natural for his left hand to do the same - but instead his right hand comes up. I also noticed that Sanchez had his palm flat with his hand facing out."
It "looked odd" he says, which explains why Clattenburg asked the opinion of assistant Jake Collins who, he believes, should be disappointed with his advice.
Hackett says there could be repercussions for Clattenburg. "I was interested to hear that Mark had apologised to the Hull players, and that is a mark of him as a referee and a man – although I am not sure his bosses at PGMOL [which oversees match officials] will be quite as pleased he apologised as referees are not encouraged to do so."
There is one way to end such controversies, says Webb in the Times. "One way around it would be to change the law to say that you cannot score a goal if the ball comes off an arm regardless of whether it was deliberate or not. That is something I would support as it would bring greater clarity."
Sign up for Today's Best Articles in your inbox
A free daily email with the biggest news stories of the day – and the best features from TheWeek.com
-
The history of Donald Trump's election conspiracy theories
The Explainer How the 2024 Republican nominee has consistently stoked baseless fears of a stolen election
By David Faris Published
-
Two ancient cities have been discovered along the Silk Road
Under the radar The discovery changed what was known about the old trade route
By Devika Rao, The Week US Published
-
'People shouldn't have to share the road with impaired drivers'
Instant Opinion Opinion, comment and editorials of the day
By Justin Klawans, The Week US Published
-
The Premier League's spending cap: levelling the playing field?
Talking Point Top clubs oppose plans to link spending to income of lowest-earning club, but rule could prevent success gap from widening
By Harriet Marsden, The Week UK Published
-
Is a new English football regulator an own goal for the game?
Talking Point PM hails 'historic moment for football fans' but West Ham owner warns it could 'ruin' Premier League
By The Week UK Published
-
English football and the etiquette of leaving the stadium early
Talking Point The belief that 'true fans stay to the end' does not always apply
By The Week UK Published
-
2023-2024 Premier League predictions: champions, relegation and golden boot
feature A look at the top flight talking points and pundit picks for the new season
By Mike Starling Published
-
Man City: can ‘one of the best sides in history’ win the treble?
feature Guardiola’s Premier League champions have two more trophies in their sights
By The Week Staff Published
-
Premier League: Man City vs. Arsenal predictions
feature What the pundits say about tonight’s title race showdown at the Etihad
By Mike Starling Last updated
-
Antonio Conte leaves Tottenham after ‘extraordinary’ rant at players
feature After another year without a trophy, Spurs are now searching for a new manager
By The Week Staff Published
-
Liverpool 7 Man Utd 0: ‘welcome to Jürgen Klopp’s Liverpool 2.0’
feature Anfield’s ‘new front three’ were on fire in the humbling of their bitter rivals
By Mike Starling Published