Alliance Theatre, Atlanta
(404) 733-4650
Article continues belowThe Week
Escape your echo chamber. Get the facts behind the news, plus analysis from multiple perspectives.
Sign up for The Week's Free Newsletters
From our morning news briefing to a weekly Good News Newsletter, get the best of The Week delivered directly to your inbox.
From our morning news briefing to a weekly Good News Newsletter, get the best of The Week delivered directly to your inbox.
The names involved certainly raise expectations, said Frank Rizzo in Variety. This new musical marries a script by Stephen King to a score by John Mellencamp, with musical direction by T Burnett Bone. King has spun a Gothic yarn about two Mississippi brothers, Jack and Andy, locked in a deadly rivalry over a local girl. And that story is told via the flashbacks of their brother Joe, who, having become a father, wants his two squabbling sons to avoid the same tragic end. But King hasn’t written a play before, and it shows. Jake and Andy “are ill-defined beyond a few broad strokes, and the dialogue is clunky.” Mellencamp’s score helps, but his bluesy songs “rarely lift the proceedings emotionally.” Unfortunately, “it takes more than a groove and gore” to engage an audience.
Yet it would be a shame to undervalue the efforts of those lower on the marquee, said Bert Osborne in The Atlanta Journal-Constitution. The names of projection designer Adam Larsen and set designer Todd Rosenthal certainly won’t “sell a lot of tickets.” Yet the way they represent the parallel universes in King’s story provides a “spectacularly spooky” experience. The actors, too, make the most of what they’re given, particularly Shuler Hensley, who’s an intense Joe, and Jake La Botz, who’s “unforgettable” as The Shape, a figure who guides the characters’ actions from the beyond. Though the show “spirals wildly out of control in its final 15 minutes,” it’s still “a pretty awesome spectacle.”