Will the Supreme Court really reflect America?
If Kagan is confirmed, she'll be the fourth New Yorker in a Catholic/Jewish, Ivy League–educated high court. Too imbalanced?

If Elena Kagan is confirmed to the Supreme Court, four of the nine justices will have grown up in New York — Kagan in Manhattan; Ruth Bader Ginsburg, Brooklyn; Sonia Sotomayor, the Bronx; and Antonin Scalia, Queens. The court would also be entirely Ivy League–educated, and consist of three Jews and six Catholics. Can such a court represent the rest of America? (Watch Elena Kagan discuss her New York roots)
No. New York is unique: While this shouldn't matter to those who judge justices on their ability to "regard the law with utter neutrality," says Kathleen Parker in The Washington Post, such a court utterly fails Obama's "ordinary-people principle" — and so does Kagan. It's daft to pretend that the "cultural marinade" of the Upper West Side is "anything close to mainstream America."
"Elena Kagan is miles away from mainstream America"
Subscribe to The Week
Escape your echo chamber. Get the facts behind the news, plus analysis from multiple perspectives.

Sign up for The Week's Free Newsletters
From our morning news briefing to a weekly Good News Newsletter, get the best of The Week delivered directly to your inbox.
From our morning news briefing to a weekly Good News Newsletter, get the best of The Week delivered directly to your inbox.
Yes. New York is the "mainstream": Maybe justices who grew up in New York can't "really understand an American 'heartland'" of small, rural towns, says Ed Kilgore at FiveThirtyEight. The same could be said of the other 80 percent of Americans who live in metro areas. Besides, only 14 New Yorkers sat on the Supreme Court before this batch, a pretty shabby number for America's legal capital.
"Kagan, New York, and 'the Heartland'"
An east-coast bias is at work: For D.C. elitists, "California may as well be the moon — a place where shallow pseudo-intellectuals work on their tans," says Kitty Felde in the Southern California Public Radio's website. We're looking at a court with four New Yorkers, while the state that one in ten Americans call home will be represented by Anthony Kennedy alone.
"Elitism and east-coast bias on the Supreme Court"
It depends on your zip code: Any evidence of a "New York bloc" will definitely lie in the eye of the beholder, says Albany Law School professor Vincent Bonventre, quoted in The New York Times. A liberal ruling by "the three [New York] women and the Jewish guy" would "make complete sense to New Yorkers," but in "the South and the Bible Belt, people are going to say, 'They don't understand the rest of America.'"
Sign up for Today's Best Articles in your inbox
A free daily email with the biggest news stories of the day – and the best features from TheWeek.com
-
The End: not the 'uncompromising masterpiece' it aspires to be
Talking Point Post-apocalyptic musical has an excellent cast – but is 'catastrophically self-indulgent'
By The Week UK Published
-
The week's best photos
In Pictures A leaning palace, massive waves, and more
By Anahi Valenzuela, The Week US Published
-
Diana Henry picks her favourite books
The Week Recommends The food writer shares works by Claire Keegan, Molly O'Neill and Richard Yates
By The Week UK Published
-
The JFK files: the truth at last?
In The Spotlight More than 64,000 previously classified documents relating the 1963 assassination of John F. Kennedy have been released by the Trump administration
By The Week Staff Published
-
'Seriously, not literally': how should the world take Donald Trump?
Today's big question White House rhetoric and reality look likely to become increasingly blurred
By Sorcha Bradley, The Week UK Published
-
Will Trump's 'madman' strategy pay off?
Today's Big Question Incoming US president likes to seem unpredictable but, this time round, world leaders could be wise to his playbook
By Sorcha Bradley, The Week UK Published
-
Democrats vs. Republicans: who are the billionaires backing?
The Explainer Younger tech titans join 'boys' club throwing money and support' behind President Trump, while older plutocrats quietly rebuke new administration
By Harriet Marsden, The Week UK Published
-
US election: where things stand with one week to go
The Explainer Harris' lead in the polls has been narrowing in Trump's favour, but her campaign remains 'cautiously optimistic'
By Harriet Marsden, The Week UK Published
-
Is Trump okay?
Today's Big Question Former president's mental fitness and alleged cognitive decline firmly back in the spotlight after 'bizarre' town hall event
By Harriet Marsden, The Week UK Published
-
The life and times of Kamala Harris
The Explainer The vice-president is narrowly leading the race to become the next US president. How did she get to where she is now?
By The Week UK Published
-
Will 'weirdly civil' VP debate move dial in US election?
Today's Big Question 'Diametrically opposed' candidates showed 'a lot of commonality' on some issues, but offered competing visions for America's future and democracy
By Harriet Marsden, The Week UK Published