Why are 186 bands suing Rolling Stone and Camel?
Indie rock bands Xiu Xiu and F****d Up have filed a class action lawsuit against R.J. Reynolds Tobacco Company and Wenner Media, the owners of Camel cigarettes and Rolling Stone magazine, respectively, for associating them with cigarettes without their co
What happened
Indie rock bands Xiu Xiu and F****d Up have filed a class action lawsuit against R.J. Reynolds Tobacco Company and Wenner Media, the owners of Camel cigarettes and Rolling Stone magazine, respectively. The suit was filed on behalf of 186 artsist and bands, and stems from a pullout advertising spread that Camel ran in the November 15th issue of Rolling Stone, which the plaintiffs claim associated them with cigarettes without their consent. The bands are seeking a published apology and as much as $195.3 billion in damages.
What the commentators said
Subscribe to The Week
Escape your echo chamber. Get the facts behind the news, plus analysis from multiple perspectives.

Sign up for The Week's Free Newsletters
From our morning news briefing to a weekly Good News Newsletter, get the best of The Week delivered directly to your inbox.
From our morning news briefing to a weekly Good News Newsletter, get the best of The Week delivered directly to your inbox.
“Remember when we speculated that marketers wouldn’t be taking advantage of indie bands if musicians could afford their own lawyers?” said Charlie Moran in Advertising Age. “Well that’s all about to change.”
Rolling Stone is going to have a tough time fighting this, said Guy Dixon in The Globe and Mail. Although the Camel ad “doesn’t mention the band’s names,” it “does suggest an association between the cigarette company and indie music in general.” It even “lists a Web address for Camel’s ‘The Farm’ campaign, where users can listen to underground bands.”
Does anyone even pay attention to those inserts? said the blog B12 Solipsism. When I picked up that issue of Rolling Stone, I “ripped” it “out, unseen, as I do for all inserts in all magazines.” I kind of I wish I hadn’t, though—I could have “put it up for sale on eBay.”
There’s some poetic justice in all of this, said Jeff Skruck in PrefixMag.com. Rolling Stone “rarely, if ever” gives “indie bands and artists” the coverage they deserve, and now the magazine’s getting sued by 186 of them. But I do feel bad for the “schmuck who storyboarded and pitched this cross-promotional fiasco to the suits—good luck on your job search.”
Sign up for Today's Best Articles in your inbox
A free daily email with the biggest news stories of the day – and the best features from TheWeek.com
It’s pretty hard not to imagine some hypocrisy in this lawsuit, said Jen Carlson in Gothamist. You really have to “wonder how many of those 186 bands filing suit actually do smoke cigarettes.”
-
Book reviews: 'The Thinking Machine: Jensen Huang, Nvidia, and the World’s Most Coveted Microchip' and 'Who Is Government? The Untold Story of Public Service'
Feature The tech titan behind Nvidia's success and the secret stories of government workers
By The Week US
-
Mario Vargas Llosa: The novelist who lectured Latin America
Feature The Peruvian novelist wove tales of political corruption and moral compromise
By The Week US
-
How to see the Lyrid meteor shower
The explainer A nice time to look to the skies
By Devika Rao, The Week US