Opinion

Did you vote for Donald Trump? Then you're not actually a Republican.

At least not as the party has defined itself for several decades

In the days since Donald Trump gave his rivals for the Republican nomination a double-digit thumping in the South Carolina primary, the bulk of political commentary has focused on the horse race. What will happen in Tuesday's Nevada caucuses? And what about in the pile of states voting on March 1? When will Ben Carson and John Kasich drop out? If Marco Rubio hopes to catch Trump, he'll have to win something soon. But where? Can Ted Cruz prevail anywhere besides Iowa and his home state of Texas?

Those are all interesting and important questions. But they shouldn't distract us from the bigger picture of what's happening right before our eyes — which is nothing less than the implosion of the Republican Party.

Consider: In the week leading up to the South Carolina primary, Donald Trump...

... unambiguously attacked the last Republican president for his decision to launch the Iraq War.

... parroted left-wing conspiracy theories about how this same president lied in making his case for the war.

... flatly asserted that "torture works."

... endorsed a policy of committing war crimes by telling the (apocryphal) story of how an American general massacred 49 Muslims a century ago in the Philippines using bullets dipped in pigs' blood (as an extra offense against Islamic law, which bans contact with swine).

... reiterated his promise to build a wall along the southern border of the United States to keep out Mexican immigrants — and added that he'd name the barrier the "Trump Wall."

... spoke positively about ObamaCare's individual mandate.

... denounced as "bad guys" a series of leading conservative commentators, including Karl Rove, George Will, Steven Hayes, and Charles Krauthammer.

And then one-third of South Carolina Republicans gave Donald Trump their votes.

Let me put this as clearly and straightforwardly as I can: A Republican Party in which a third or more of the voters are ready and willing to vote for such a candidate is not the same party that elected Ronald Reagan, George H.W. Bush, and George W. Bush, or that chose John McCain and Mitt Romney as its standard-bearer.

But the situation is even more dire than that — though members of the Republican establishment and mainstream conservative movement are trying very hard to deny it.

Most of these willful optimists insist that Trump will soon fade, with Rubio surging to the head of the delegate pack. This prediction isn't completely delusional. Trump's success can't be disentangled from his great good fortune in running against such a sharply divided field. Trump has yet to crack the mid-30s in support, and his ceiling is unlikely to go much higher than that, with the non-Trump candidates dividing the remaining 60-something percent of the vote amongst themselves. In a two-man race, it becomes quite likely that the sole non-Trump option would prevail.

But when it comes to the future of the Republican Party, this doesn't much matter — because we now know that roughly one-third of the party has gone rogue. In the short term, this raises the question of what these rogue voters will do in November if Trump isn't the nominee. Is it likely they will show up to vote for Rubio, the candidate ideologically closest to George W. Bush? I think that's highly unlikely, and that it could doom the non-Trump Republican nominee this year, no matter who it ends up being.

But more ominous for Republicans is the longer-term.

How can the GOP continue to push the same agenda when one-third of the party wants it to make a radical break from its past and stand for something fundamentally different? Trump outflanks the party from the right on immigration and terrorism, outflanks it from the left on taxes, benefits, and a range of other domestic policy issues, and ridicules just about everyone else in the party for their rank stupidity and for contributing to a decline in the country that he alone can reverse.

A third of Republican voters endorse this profoundly anti-Republican message.

As I've argued before, that appears to leave two possible paths forward for the GOP. One is for the party as a whole to shift ideological direction to appeal explicitly to the rogue third of the party — though that could easily alienate a good portion of the party's other two-thirds. And that leaves the second option, which is for the party to break apart, with the rogue Republicans forming the base of some new party.

The path that leads to the second option would probably involve Trump failing to win the nomination this year and bolting from the GOP to form a third party — or Trump or some other political opportunist doing something similar in 2020.

Lest Democrats succumb too quickly to schadenfreude at the prospect of the GOP breaking into two and clearing a path to landslide victories for the Donkey Party, they should ponder a couple of recent New York Times stories on Trump's appeal to a "certain kind of Democrat" — namely, a working-class white Democrat with strong union ties. To test the thesis of these articles, Democrats should watch closely during upcoming open primaries to see how many Dems cross over to vote for Trump.

If the number comes to anything more than a trivial amount, that would open up a chilling possibility: that the ethnic-nationalist third party emerging from the GOP could draw support from the Democrats as well, effectively redrawing the ideological and demographic shape of both major parties.

That could herald the most significant change in the American political system — and inaugurate a period of greater political instability — than this country has seen in a very long time.

There's a reason why the old saying about living in interesting times is described as a curse.

More From...

Picture of Damon LinkerDamon Linker
Read All
A curtain falls
A stage.
Opinion

A curtain falls

Trump loses his grip on a Trumpified GOP
Donald Trump.
Opinion

Trump loses his grip on a Trumpified GOP

Letter from a demoralized Pennsylvania voter
PA candidates.
Opinion

Letter from a demoralized Pennsylvania voter

Let people vent to SCOTUS on abortion
Brett Kavanaugh.
Opinion

Let people vent to SCOTUS on abortion

Recommended

What is the Supreme Court doing with the Voting Rights Act?
The Supreme Court.
Briefing

What is the Supreme Court doing with the Voting Rights Act?

Texas error means National Guard troops on border mission face surprise tax bills
Greg Abbott
Operation Lone Star

Texas error means National Guard troops on border mission face surprise tax bills

Sen. Ben Sasse will likely soon resign to accept job as university president
Ben Sasse.
time to say goodbye

Sen. Ben Sasse will likely soon resign to accept job as university president

Biden pardons thousands convicted of marijuana possession
Joe Biden
Blaze it

Biden pardons thousands convicted of marijuana possession

Most Popular

Survey reveals less than half of Americans plan to get flu shot this season
influenza vaccine syringe photo
Masks trump flu vax

Survey reveals less than half of Americans plan to get flu shot this season

Russian war bloggers warn Ukraine is threatening Kherson defensive lines
Ukraine inroads in Kherson
War on the Rocks

Russian war bloggers warn Ukraine is threatening Kherson defensive lines

Lizzo invited for an encore flute performance at James Madison's home
Lizzo
play it again sam?

Lizzo invited for an encore flute performance at James Madison's home