Superdelegates, explained

Everything you need to know about the Democratic powerbrokers who may decide the 2016 election

By just about any measure, Hillary Clinton leads Bernie Sanders in the race for the Democratic presidential nomination. But it's only when you count her superdelegates that the lead looks positively insurmountable.

The Democrats have so far held 35 nominating contests. Clinton has won 20 of them, and Sanders 15.

A Democratic candidate needs 2,383 total delegates to secure the nomination. Clinton has 1,243 pledged delegates to Sanders' 980.

But then there's the superdelegates. Clinton has the declared support of 469 of them. Sanders has a meager 31.

These superdelegates are not bound to follow the will of the voters, nor are they required to stay true to the candidate they've pledged to support. But they may well decide the Democratic race. It's certainly possible, and perhaps even likely, that neither Clinton nor Sanders will get to 2,383 without superdelegates.

So who are these superdelegates, and how does their power work? Here's what you need to know:

Who gets to be a superdelegate?A superdelegate is typically an elite member of the Democratic Party falling into one of three categories:

1. A major elected official, including senators, members of the House, governors, and leaders from each state's Democratic Party. For example, New York Gov. Andrew Cuomo and Massachusetts Sen. Elizabeth Warren are superdelegates.

2. A notable party figure, such as former and current presidents and vice presidents. For example, former President Bill Clinton and Vice President Joe Biden are superdelegates.

3. Select leaders of organizations affiliated with the Democratic National Committee. These select party elders get their superdelegate status automatically by virtue of the fact that they've been elected to public office. For example, DNC Chair Debbie Wasserman Schultz and Louis Elrod of Young Democrats of America are superdelegates.

How many Democratic superdelegates are there?712. They control about 15 percent of the nominating process. The remaining 85 percent is controlled by delegates apportioned by the results of primaries and caucuses.

How are superdelegates different from regular delegates?Superdelegates are free to support whichever candidate they choose, even if that candidate is not the voters' pick. As for normal delegates: Each state has a different system for selecting who they'll send to the convention as a delegate. But unlike superdelegates, delegates are allotted to candidates in proportion to their share of the vote in the state's primary or caucus and are then pledged to vote for that candidate.

Why do we have superdelegates in the first place?For most of the Democratic Party's history, party elders picked the nominee. It was only in recent decades that the Democratic Party began experimenting with the idea of opening up the nomination process to give voters more of a say in choosing the nominee.

Democrats began using primaries and caucuses to select pledged delegates in 1972. In that election, Democrats ended up with a nominee — Sen. George McGovern — who was absolutely destroyed in the general election: Richard Nixon carried 49 states to McGovern's one.

In 1976, Democrats ended up with yet another nominee — Jimmy Carter — who didn't do particularly well on the national stage. While Carter eked out a victory in the 1976 election in the wake of the Republican administration's disastrous Watergate scandal, he was steamrolled by Ronald Reagan in 1980, with Reagan winning 44 states to Carter's six.

Party elites saw "a need for there to be a voice for the establishment within the party to not necessarily overturn the will of the voters, but to nudge along a nominee who would be well equipped to win during the general election — to avoid nominees like George McGovern and Jimmy Carter," University of Georgia political science professor Josh Putnam told CBS News.

The resulting solution, settled upon in the early 1980s, was a superdelegate system in which party elites could put their thumbs on the scale. The New York Times reports that party elders claimed it "created a more stable and predictable nominating process that favors mainstream candidates and policies."

Isn't the Democratic Party's superdelegate process undemocratic?That's what critics argue. But the Democratic Party maintains that, as "open" and "democratic" as it may sound to to put the choice entirely in the hands of voters, the results aren't so hot. As The Washington Post points out, Democratic voters do not get better representation when their party's nominee gets decimated by a Republican, as happened just before the party's adoption of superdelegates. Superdelegates are meant to be a pragmatic check on desires of voters.

So, how does this all factor into 2016?The reason people are up in arms about the Democratic Party's superdelegate system is all about the chasm between the opinions of Democratic voters and that of party elites in this election. While Sen. Bernie Sanders (I-Vt.) and Hillary Clinton are relatively close in their respective delegate counts and in national polling, Clinton is absolutely crushing Sanders among superdelegates.

But, as The Washington Post notes, Sanders supporters' complaints aren't out of the ordinary: "[D]uring years when [superdelegates have] seemed poised to swing a nomination battle — in 1984 and 2008 — disadvantaged factions have been quick to cry foul." Everything old, it seems, is new again.


The 'Trump app' will be the insurrection on steroids
Donald Trump.
Picture of Damon LinkerDamon Linker

The 'Trump app' will be the insurrection on steroids

Will Democrats give up tax hikes to save the world?
A hundred dollar bill.
Picture of James PethokoukisJames Pethokoukis

Will Democrats give up tax hikes to save the world?

DOJ reportedly added 2 top prosecutors to Matt Gaetz sex trafficking case
Matt Gaetz
Gaetz Investigation

DOJ reportedly added 2 top prosecutors to Matt Gaetz sex trafficking case

Biden explains Kyrsten Sinema's positions in Build Back Better negotiations
Joe Biden
Decoding Sinemanchin

Biden explains Kyrsten Sinema's positions in Build Back Better negotiations

Most Popular

NYC to impose vaccine mandate for all city workers
NYPD officers
'it's time'

NYC to impose vaccine mandate for all city workers

The American 'Great Resignation' by the numbers
Help wanted sign
Help Wanted

The American 'Great Resignation' by the numbers

Rep. Jeff Fortenberry indicted on charges of lying to federal investigators
Rep. Jeff Fortenberry.
see you in court

Rep. Jeff Fortenberry indicted on charges of lying to federal investigators