“Typical Spielberg,” said Kevin Maher in The Times. “Only he could manage to remake arguably the greatest musical of all without falling flat on his face.” This is no radical reinvention, however: he has deftly shuffled a few numbers, added a character and dropped in a “dash of political subtext”, while approaching the spirit of the 1961 film “with unashamed reverence”. Ansel Elgort plays lovestruck Tony with a “hint of earnestness” that will be familiar to fans of the original; newcomer Rachel Zegler matches Natalie Wood for charisma, while outclassing her vocally (Wood was famously dubbed by Marni Nixon); the dance routines are based on the original choreography, but “expanded and elaborated”; the standout songs are still “ineffably poignant”; and the frames “drip with vintage colour” as if freshly “unearthed from a Tinseltown vault”. “This is West Side Story as you have never seen it before, exactly as it was before and more like before than ever.”
“I gave my heart to this poignant American fairy-tale of doomed love,” said Peter Bradshaw in The Guardian. Bernstein’s score and Sondheim’s lyrics “blaze out with fierce new clarity”, and the visuals are “staggering”, reviving 1950s New York with fearless theatricality. “On the big screen the effect is hyperreal, as if you have somehow hallucinated your way back 70 years.” Yes, it all looks and feels absolutely right, said Christina Newland in The i Paper, and yet something is lacking. Spielberg could have infused the story with new life. Instead, he has produced a film that has “all the strengths and flaws” of its predecessor, and feels instantly stale. Really, what was the point?
The Week
Escape your echo chamber. Get the facts behind the news, plus analysis from multiple perspectives.
Sign up for The Week's Free Newsletters
From our morning news briefing to a weekly Good News Newsletter, get the best of The Week delivered directly to your inbox.
From our morning news briefing to a weekly Good News Newsletter, get the best of The Week delivered directly to your inbox.
-
How China rewrote the history of its WWII victoryIn Depth Though the nationalist government led China to victory in 1945, this is largely overlooked in modern Chinese commemorations
-
September 3 editorial cartoonsCartoons Wednesday’s political cartoons include news from the war front in Ukraine, RFK Jr. riding the Grim Reaper, and a Donald Trump cabinet meeting
-
Why high-street coffee chains may have had their dayIn the Spotlight Rising costs of coffee, energy and payroll, plus growing appetite for luxury drinks like matcha, has caused boom in independent and speciality coffee shops
-
Woof! Britain's love affair with dogsThe Explainer The UK's canine population is booming. What does that mean for man's best friend?
-
Millet: Life on the Land – an 'absorbing' exhibitionThe Week Recommends Free exhibition at the National Gallery showcases the French artist's moving paintings of rural life
-
Thomasina Miers picks her favourite booksThe Week Recommends The food writer shares works by Arundhati Roy, Claire Keegan and Charles Dickens
-
6 laid-back homes for surfersFeature Featuring a home near a world-renowned surf spot in Hawaii and a house built to withstand the elements in South Carolina
-
Twelfth Night or What You Will: a 'riotous' late-summer jamboreeThe Week Recommends Robin Belfield's 'carnivalesque' new staging at Shakespeare's Globe is 'joyfully tongue-in-cheek'
-
Hostage: Netflix's 'fun, fast and brash potboiler'The Week Recommends Suranne Jones is 'relentlessly defiant' as prime minister Abigail Dalton
-
Music reviews: Chance the Rapper, Cass McCombs, and Molly TuttleFeature "Star Line," "Interior Live Oak," and "So Long Little Miss Sunshine"
-
Film reviews: Eden and Honey Don't!Feature Seekers of a new utopia spiral into savagery and a queer private eye prowls a high-desert town
