Good review: ‘fascinating psychological theatre’ starring David Tennant
This quietly terrifying play offers a ‘surprising and perceptive psychological slant’ on the Nazis’ rise
 
“Few actors can project charismatic affability better than David Tennant,” said Dominic Cavendish in The Daily Telegraph. And fewer still have his ability to switch off the charm in an instant and “go dead behind the eyes”, as we discovered when he played the serial killer Dennis Nielsen in ITV’s Des.
In Good, set in pre-war Germany, Tennant plays another “seemingly ordinary man” – a liberal-minded literature professor, John Halder, who gradually becomes part of the Nazi “killing machine”, washes his hands of his Jewish best friend, and ends up arguing for the Final Solution.
First performed in 1981, C.P. Taylor’s quietly terrifying play offers a “surprising and perceptive psychological slant” on the Nazis’ rise. Halder is not “spurred by rousing speeches” and nationalist passion – but rather by bourgeois insularity, “self-interest and self-absorption”. And Tennant’s performance is “hypnotic”.
The Week
Escape your echo chamber. Get the facts behind the news, plus analysis from multiple perspectives.
 
Sign up for The Week's Free Newsletters
From our morning news briefing to a weekly Good News Newsletter, get the best of The Week delivered directly to your inbox.
From our morning news briefing to a weekly Good News Newsletter, get the best of The Week delivered directly to your inbox.
This is “fascinating psychological theatre with the feel of a fever dream”, amplified in Dominic Cooke’s production by bold, non-naturalistic staging, said Arifa Akbar in The Guardian. Vicki Mortimer’s set is “grey and prison-like”; scenes change abruptly. The strangeness of all this is explained by a reveal at the end, but “the payoff isn’t quite surprising enough”. Still, there is “enough intrigue, intellect and fine acting to keep us rapt”, and Tennant is “spellbinding in his ordinariness, not hiding Halder’s venality yet ensuring he remains human”.
Tennant’s is a “chilling performance rather than a moving one”, said Sarah Crompton on What’s on Stage. It falls to Elliott Levey, as Maurice, Halder’s best friend, to locate the play’s emotion, and he brilliantly conveys both Maurice’s humour and rising panic.
Sharon Small is equally persuasive, said Dominic Maxwell in The Times: she has to switch between parts – Halder’s wives, his mother, a Nazi soldier – and does so in a way that is “clear, unfussy, instant”. Don’t expect fireworks from this excellent revival. “What you get is something stranger, more insidious, and I suspect much more memorable.”
Harold Pinter Theatre, London SW1
A free daily email with the biggest news stories of the day – and the best features from TheWeek.com
- 
 Is the job market frozen or faltering? Is the job market frozen or faltering?Today's Big Question Layoffs raise alarms while young workers eye law school 
- 
 Pentagon unable to name boat strike casualties Pentagon unable to name boat strike casualtiesSpeed Read The Pentagon has so far acknowledged 14 strikes 
- 
 41 political cartoons for October 2025 41 political cartoons for October 2025Cartoons Editorial cartoonists take on Donald Trump, ICE, Stephen Miller, the government shutdown, a peace plan in the Middle East, Jeffrey Epstein, and more. 
- 
 6 trailside homes for hikers 6 trailside homes for hikersFeature Featuring a roof deck with skyline views in California and a home with access to private trails in Montana 
- 
 Lazarus: Harlan Coben’s ‘embarrassingly compelling’ thriller Lazarus: Harlan Coben’s ‘embarrassingly compelling’ thrillerThe Week Recommends Bill Nighy and Sam Claflin play father-and-son psychiatrists in this ‘precision-engineered’ crime drama 
- 
 The Rose Field: a ‘nail-biting’ end to The Book of Dust series The Rose Field: a ‘nail-biting’ end to The Book of Dust seriesThe Week Recommends Philip Pullman’s superb new novel brings the trilogy to a ‘fitting’ conclusion 
- 
 Nigerian Modernism: an ‘entrancing, enlightening exhibition’ Nigerian Modernism: an ‘entrancing, enlightening exhibition’The Week Recommends Tate Modern’s ‘revelatory’ show includes 250 works examining Nigerian art pre- and post independence 
- 
 The Mastermind: Josh O’Connor stars in unconventional art heist movie The Mastermind: Josh O’Connor stars in unconventional art heist movieThe Week Recommends Kelly Reichardt cements her status as the ‘queen of slow cinema’ with her latest film 
- 
 Critics’ choice: Watering holes for gourmands Critics’ choice: Watering holes for gourmandsFeature An endless selection of Mexican spirits, a Dublin-inspired bar, and an upscale Baltimore pub 
- 
 Film reviews: Springsteen: Deliver Me From Nowhere, If I Had Legs I’d Kick You, Frankenstein, and Blue Moon Film reviews: Springsteen: Deliver Me From Nowhere, If I Had Legs I’d Kick You, Frankenstein, and Blue MoonFeature A rock star on the rise turns inward, a stressed mother begins to unravel, and more 
- 
 Beth Macy’s 6 favorite books about living in a divided nation Beth Macy’s 6 favorite books about living in a divided nationFeature The journalist recommends works by Nicholas Buccola, Matthew Desmond, and more