Fisherman’s Friends could be described as the ultimate “buoyband”, said Dominic Cavendish in The Daily Telegraph – a group of grizzled Cornish fishermen who miraculously netted a £1m record deal and stormed the charts in 2010 with an album of time-honoured sea shanties.
Their heartwarming story provided the basis for a film in 2019. Now, it has been turned into a charming if lightweight stage musical – and if you like sea shanties, you are very likely to love it.
The show includes enough of them (almost 30) “to sink a battleship”, and it has a supersized cast of 25 actors and musicians too. “When it’s all hands on deck, it’s quite a sight to behold: the replica quayside set more bustling than St Ives at tourist season high-tide.” What I yearned for, though, was a bit more drama. This is a pleasurable evening, but some “Sturm und Drang wouldn’t go amiss”.
The Week
Escape your echo chamber. Get the facts behind the news, plus analysis from multiple perspectives.
Sign up for The Week's Free Newsletters
From our morning news briefing to a weekly Good News Newsletter, get the best of The Week delivered directly to your inbox.
From our morning news briefing to a weekly Good News Newsletter, get the best of The Week delivered directly to your inbox.
There is a feeling that this is a story we’ve heard quite often before, said Miriam Gillinson in The Guardian, possibly in more suitable forms. Still, it has a solid script, and there are flashes of “humour and cynicism”, especially in the tension between locals and tourists.
Director James Grieve has “clearly worked hard to hold on to the rough-hewn authenticity” that made the original group a success. The lighting and set design are “muted” rather than brash. And the excellent performances, particularly from James Gaddas as the group’s gruff lead singer Jim, are “suitably un-showy”.
“As a piece of theatre, it is all a bit safe” – but it delivers “earworm after earworm”: this is a show that “knows its target audience” and it “lands them all night”, said Kris Hallett on What’s On Stage.
During last week’s press performance, the weather outside was “doing a decent impression of an Atlantic storm”, said Clive Davis in The Times. But inside the theatre, as we listened to a series of “soul-stirring” sea shanties performed with gusto, “we were, metaphorically speaking anyway, snugly tucked up in front of a roaring pub fire, hot toddies in our hands”. It’s that kind of experience that this “heart-on-sleeve” show offers, and it surely deserves to “pack them in”.
Leeds Grand Theatre; until 19 November, then on tour
-
A crowded field of Democrats is filling up the California governor’s raceIn the Spotlight Over a dozen Democrats have declared their candidacy
-
Nitazene is elusively raising opioid deathsThe explainer The drug is usually consumed accidentally
-
Can medical debt hurt your credit?The explainer The short answer is yes, though it depends on the credit scoring mode
-
Nick Clegg picks his favourite booksThe Week Recommends The former deputy prime minister shares works by J.M. Coetzee, Marcel Theroux and Conrad Russell
-
Park Avenue: New York family drama with a ‘staggeringly good’ castThe Week Recommends Fiona Shaw and Katherine Waterston have a ‘combative chemistry’ as a mother and daughter at a crossroads
-
Jay Kelly: ‘deeply mischievous’ Hollywood satire starring George ClooneyThe Week Recommends Noah Baumbach’s smartly scripted Hollywood satire is packed with industry in-jokes
-
Motherland: a ‘brilliantly executed’ feminist history of modern RussiaThe Week Recommends Moscow-born journalist Julia Ioffe examines the women of her country over the past century
-
Music reviews: Rosalía and Mavis Staplesfeature “Lux” and “Sad and Beautiful World”
-
6 homes for entertainingFeature Featuring a heated greenhouse in Pennsylvania and a glamorous oasis in California
-
Film reviews: ‘Jay Kelly’ and ‘Sentimental Value’Feature A movie star looks back on his flawed life and another difficult dad seeks to make amends
-
6 homes on the Gulf CoastFeature Featuring an elegant townhouse in New Orleans’ French Quarter and contemporary coastal retreat in Texas
