The vaccine deployment we could have had

Former President Donald Trump's emergence as a vocal proponent of the COVID-19 vaccines has raised an interesting counterfactual question: What if he had spent the final weeks of his administration touting one of his greatest success stories — Operation Warp Speed and the development of these vaccines — rather than trying to wish away his failure to win re-election?

It's possible the vaccine skepticism that has taken hold in some corners of the right could have been prevented. Yes, there still would've been alternate voices promoting anti-vaxx sentiments, and some people, particularly those failed by the medical community during the opioid crisis, would have remained susceptible to it. But the political tribalism that has sprung up around the pandemic may well have played out differently.

During the 2020 campaign, then-candidates Joe Biden and Kamala Harris both expressed at least some concern about Trump rushing a vaccine to market, despite the shots being critical to their own approach to the coronavirus. Had they kept up that line of critique while Trump touted shots, Republicans could easily have been persuaded to take ownership of the vaccines.

The Week

Escape your echo chamber. Get the facts behind the news, plus analysis from multiple perspectives.

SUBSCRIBE & SAVE

Sign up for The Week's Free Newsletters

From our morning news briefing to a weekly Good News Newsletter, get the best of The Week delivered directly to your inbox.

From our morning news briefing to a weekly Good News Newsletter, get the best of The Week delivered directly to your inbox.

Sign up

That's not the only counterfactual to consider: What if the people trying to influence Trump on his pandemic response had appealed more to his vanity? President Biden's recent qualified praise of Trump on the vaccines has clearly had an impact on the ex-president. And his early approach to the virus was more malleable than we now remember it: He elevated Anthony Fauci, presided over economic restrictions that are now unthinkable (he turned against state-level lockdowns, but did not begin as an opponent), and was not as ideological as many of his supporters despite a clear preference for reopening as quickly as possible. Fauci himself played this game until Trump's re-election prospects seemed unlikely. Could it have been played better?

In fact, if Trump had focused on vaccines rather than the 2020 election, it's likely Biden would have enlisted the 45th president in outreach efforts earlier and less equivocally. Jan. 6 obviously made this more difficult.

Maybe Trump was never likely to focus his energies on something other than fighting the "loser" label. Certainly vaccine hesitancy has now hardened among the remaining holdouts. Still, as omicron spreads, it's worth wondering what might have been.