Recent developments in generative artificial intelligence have educators from elementary to university seemingly fighting an uphill battle as they struggle to manage students’ dependence on the technology. Meanwhile, one company has decided to fully embrace the new tools. But critics question whether replacing teachers with AI is worth the risk.
How does Alpha School work? The AI-powered private school was founded in 2014 by MacKenzie Price, an educational podcaster and the founder of the AI tutor 2 Hour Learning, and software billionaire Joe Liemandt and has several branches across the country, with plans to expand. The school’s recent rise has “coincided with technological leaps in what artificial intelligence can do,” said CNN.
Students typically start the day with a group activity that introduces a life skill before sitting down in front of “laptops, plug-in headsets or even virtual reality sets to learn academics” through an AI tutor, said CNN. The program’s two-hour curriculum includes “four 30-minute sessions in math, science, social studies and language,” as well as “20 minutes of additional learning concepts, like test-taking skills.” Instead of traditional teachers, the schools employ “human guides” who do not “manage grades or curriculum” but can offer “specialized teaching, like handwriting.”
“Harnessing AI thoughtfully will be critical to expanding opportunity and preparing students for tomorrow’s workforce,” said Education Secretary Linda McMahon during a visit to an Alpha campus in September. The school is an “exemplary” case of what tech can do for American education.
Is the program effective? Despite McMahon’s stamp of approval, the AI-driven program has attracted growing criticism. For more than a dozen former employees, students and parents, “what they expected from Alpha School wasn’t what it delivered,” said Wired.
Former guides, “many of whom requested anonymity because they fear negative consequences,” say Alpha’s educational philosophy was “driven by software metrics and, sometimes, Liemandt’s whims,” said the outlet. Alpha wanted to “prepare students for a hypercompetitive ‘late-capitalism, dog-eat-dog’ environment,” said one guide to Wired.
Experts say there’s “little outside scrutiny” of Alpha’s model and “how successful it really is at teaching children,” said CNN. A major concern is that Alpha refuses to “allow any independent research to evaluate the claims or to really scrutinize what’s going on,” said Victor Lee, an associate professor at Stanford University’s Graduate School of Education, to CNN. That “sort of implies there’s something to hide.” |