SNP’s big secret: ‘what they really want is a Tory win’
Nicola Sturgeon accused of ‘trash talking’ Ed Miliband because she doesn’t really want a pact with Labour

Are the SNP “trash-talking” Ed Miliband because they really want David Cameron re-elected?
One of the more intriguing encountesr in tonight’s seven-way will be that between Labour leader Ed Miliband and Scottish Nationalist leader Nicola Sturgeon.
The anti-Tory rhetoric of Sturgeon and her predecessor Alex Salmond is regarded with deep distrust by Labour.
Subscribe to The Week
Escape your echo chamber. Get the facts behind the news, plus analysis from multiple perspectives.

Sign up for The Week's Free Newsletters
From our morning news briefing to a weekly Good News Newsletter, get the best of The Week delivered directly to your inbox.
From our morning news briefing to a weekly Good News Newsletter, get the best of The Week delivered directly to your inbox.
They believe the SNP really want a Cameron government because that’s their best route to independence. (Remember - with no Scottish seats upsetting the maths, the Conservatives would have the chance to rule at Westminster for the foreseeable future.)
The risk of any pact between Labour and the SNP is that it would diminish the argument that Scotland can only prosper by cutting its ties with Westminster.
The view is summed up on the Labour List website by regular blogger Sonny Hundal who points out that in a recent interview Nicola Sturgeon labelled Miliband as “slightly weak” and said later that the SNP would “keep [Labour] honest”.
“Who goes into serious negotiations by slagging off their potential partner as ‘weak” and dishonest’?” asks Hundal. “In the US they call it ‘trash talking’ – insulting your opponent ahead of combat. It’s almost like the SNP want to antagonise Miliband and create a bad atmosphere before any talks take place.”
Why? Because the Nationalists want to give the impression to Scottish voters that they oppose the re-election of the much loathed (north of the border) Tories but actually have no desire to team up with Miliband’s party.
Says Hundal: “The SNP aren’t serious about working with Labour – this is a charade so they can later walk away from any deal and blame Miliband for not offering everything.”
In a similar vein, Ed Balls, the shadow chancellor, bracketed the SNP and the Tories in a speech in Glasgow. They shared a consensus, he said, that no new investment is required in Scotland to end austerity in the coming year. By contrast, his first Labour budget would end "Tory austerity".
The hostility to the Scottish Nationalists extends across the Labour Party. Left-wing Labour MPs have sharply rebuffed overtures from the SNP for a progressive bloc with the Greens and Welsh nationalists after the general election.
According to The Guardian, the SNP would seek to make alliances opposing fracking, Trident and austerity. But Jeremy Corbyn and John McDonnell, of the socialist Campaign Group in the Commons, dispute the SNP’s left-wing credentials.
Corbyn said the SNP government in Edinburgh had handed ScotRail to a private contractor, and their proposals to cut corporation tax were hardly an act of redistribution.
“I do question the assumption that they’re a massive left-wing force," he says. "Yes, they do oppose Trident and yes they’re against austerity, but the idea they’re a socialist party is far off the mark, actually.”
McDonnell said: “Given its track record in Scotland in supporting cuts in public spending, a race to the bottom on tax and privatising rail and ferries, there is a huge divide between what socialists in the Labour Party stand for and SNP nationalists.”
A free daily email with the biggest news stories of the day – and the best features from TheWeek.com
-
How generative AI is changing the way we write and speak
In The Spotlight ChatGPT and other large language model tools are quietly influencing which words we use
-
How long can Nato keep Donald Trump happy?
Today's Big Question Military alliance pulls out all the stops to woo US president on his peacemaker victory lap
-
Easy Money: the Charles Ponzi Story – an 'enlightening' podcast
The Week Recommends Apple Original podcast explores the 'fascinating' tale of the man who gave the investment scam its name
-
Is the G7 still relevant?
Talking Point Donald Trump's early departure cast a shadow over this week's meeting of the world's major democracies
-
Angela Rayner: Labour's next leader?
Today's Big Question A leaked memo has sparked speculation that the deputy PM is positioning herself as the left-of-centre alternative to Keir Starmer
-
Is Starmer's plan to send migrants overseas Rwanda 2.0?
Today's Big Question Failed asylum seekers could be removed to Balkan nations under new government plans
-
Ed Miliband, Tony Blair and the climate 'credibility gap'
Talking Point Comments by former PM Tony Blair have opened up Labour to attacks over its energy policies
-
Has Starmer put Britain back on the world stage?
Talking Point UK takes leading role in Europe on Ukraine and Starmer praised as credible 'bridge' with the US under Trump
-
Left on read: Labour's WhatsApp dilemma
Talking Point Andrew Gwynne has been sacked as health minister over messages posted in a Labour WhatsApp group
-
New Year's Honours: why the controversy?
Today's Big Question London Mayor Sadiq Khan and England men's football manager Gareth Southgate have both received a knighthood despite debatable records
-
John Prescott: was he Labour's last link to the working class?
Today's Big Quesiton 'A total one-off': tributes have poured in for the former deputy PM and trade unionist