Trouble in China: ‘triple shock’ has taken its toll

Power cuts have shut down many factories in China

(Image credit: Hector Retamal/AFP via Getty Images)

Many economists expected China’s growth to trend lower in the second half of 2021, said Jonathan Cheng in The Wall Street Journal. But the scale of the slowdown has proved much “sharper than expected”. The world’s second-largest economy grew by 4.9% in the third quarter – way down on the previous quarter’s 7.9% – reflecting a range of negative factors. Beijing’s crackdown on the technology, private education and property sectors was always going to push growth lower. But to that has been added a series of “energy snafus” caused by soaring coal prices and aggressive green targets, as well as major supply chain disruptions. None of these problems are going away.

The supply-chain crisis: what’s going on? Investing in China: what do the experts think? Evergrande: why China’s property crisis matters for the world

Coal futures in China “notched up another record this week”, said Dan Murtaugh on Bloomberg – bad news for a nation reliant on the fossil fuel for more than half its energy needs. Indeed, with winter approaching, China may have little choice but “to set aside ambitious plans to cut carbon emissions” and ramp up coal production, said Yen Nee Lee on CNBC. Power cuts have been reported in 20 provinces across China since mid-August, causing “production halts at many factories”. Call it “a triple shock”, said The Economist: “power cuts, the pandemic and a property slowdown” have “taken their toll”. More than a year and a half after Covid-19 first struck, “China is reporting growth rates that were unheard of before the pandemic”, and most economists think growth will slow even further in the last quarter of the year–to 4% or below. Increased coal production could temporarily ease the country’s “acute power crisis”, but China’s property sector, hitherto a “perennial engine of growth” (contributing more than a quarter of China’s GDP) is more difficult to fix. Regulators “trying to curb speculative demand” and “limit the excessive borrowing of homebuilders” have brought “dangers to a head”.

China’s central bank describes the stricken property giant Evergrande, with its vast $300bn in liabilities, as a one-off case in a healthy industry. Not so, said the FT. Evergrande is merely the biggest of a bad bunch. This week, another developer, Sinic Holdings, added to “a growing list of defaults”, amid “a slew of downgrades from international rating agencies”. Meanwhile, sales of new homes are slowing sharply, and higher borrowing costs are making refinancing difficult. The threat to the global economy is clear, said Yawen Chen on Reuters Breakingviews. “At risk is $2trn of Chinese annual demand for foreign goods and services.” “Better a little loss than a long sorrow”, runs the Chinese proverb. We must hope for the first, but “buckle up” for the second.