How Kevin McCarthy 'dug his own grave' in his failed bid to remain House speaker

"Bring it on," Rep. Kevin McCarthy (R-Calif.) said Sunday on CBS's "Face the Nation," confidently predicting he would "survive" Rep. Matt Gaetz's (R-Fla.) looming motion to oust him as House speaker. "Let's get over with it and let's start governing."

"Bring it on," McCarthy repeated Monday, this time on X, formerly known as Twitter. Gaetz did, filing a motion Monday night to vacate the speaker's chair. On Tuesday, seven Republicans and 208 Democrats joined him and pushed that motion over the finish line, and McCarthy was evicted from the speaker's office. The House was leaderless and will not start governing again until Republicans elect a new speaker.

How did McCarthy go from the top elected Republican in America and second in line for the presidency to just another congressman from California? "He dug his own grave," one Democratic House member told The Washington Post. Here are some of McCarthy's missteps on his path to becoming the shortest-tenured House speaker in a century and the first to be voted out by his own colleagues.

How McCarthy lost 8 Republicans

The animosity between Gaetz and McCarthy was palpable and personal, but "the proximate cause of McCarthy's fall was his decision, during his agonizing 15-ballot ascent to the speakership in January, to accept a change in House rules that allowed a single member to file a motion to remove him," Ronald Brownstein wrote at The Atlantic. 

That's how Gaetz, one of the hardliners who made lowering that threshold a precondition for McCarthy's election, was able to unilaterally force a vote on his continued speakership. But Gaetz still needed at least five more Republicans to join him in his motion to vacate, and he got seven. Many of them cited a "lack of trust in McCarthy," The Wall Street Journal reported. 

The Week

Escape your echo chamber. Get the facts behind the news, plus analysis from multiple perspectives.

SUBSCRIBE & SAVE

Sign up for The Week's Free Newsletters

From our morning news briefing to a weekly Good News Newsletter, get the best of The Week delivered directly to your inbox.

From our morning news briefing to a weekly Good News Newsletter, get the best of The Week delivered directly to your inbox.

Sign up

Time and again, McCarthy's GOP critics said, he "would make a commitment to them for some legislation or favor, only to learn that he had some other commitment to another set of Republicans that was in direct conflict," the Post reported. Several of his GOP detractors pointed to McCarthy's reversal on funding the government with a stopgap bill to avert a shutdown over the weekend. "He had told conservatives for weeks that he wouldn't pass legislation with Democrats — only to decide to do just that in a last-minute pivot," the Post added. "Conservatives were infuriated."

Most of the eight Republicans who voted to oust McCarthy are on the GOP's hard right, but Rep. Nancy Mace (R-S.C.) is not. "I've made deals with Kevin McCarthy, with the speaker, that he has not kept to help women in this country," she explained. "When you shake my hand and you make a promise and you don't keep it, there are consequences to those actions."

Why Democrats didn't save his gavel

In the days before Tuesday's vote, "Democrats had wrestled with whether to help" rescue McCarthy "or at least to stay out of the effort to oust him," The New York Times reported. But he never publicly asked for their help, and their "disdain" for McCarthy "ultimately overrode any political will they had to save him." A closed-door caucus meeting Tuesday "quickly became an airing of grievances."

"There are lots of reasons Democrats dislike McCarthy," the Post reported. He rehabilitated former President Donald Trump soon after denouncing him for the Jan. 6, 2021, attack on the Capitol, tried to thwart Jan. 6 investigations, and "just launched an impeachment inquiry into President Biden over 'allegations,'" the Post added. "But the last straw for them was seeing McCarthy on TV over the weekend trying to blame Democrats for the near-shutdown." 

In their caucus meeting, Democrats watched a video of McCarthy claiming they had wanted to shut down the government, and they were "outraged" at his misrepresentation of events, Rep. Gerry Connolly (D-Va.) told the Post. "His performance was a very clarifying event for Democrats." 

"Nobody trusts Kevin McCarthy, and why should they?" said Rep. Pramila Jayapal (D-Wash.).

Democrats, especially moderate, said they would have aided McCarthy if he had asked for their help and offered some small concessions. But he did neither. "Speaker McCarthy has repeatedly chosen to weaken the institution by bending to extremists rather than collaborating across the aisle," said Rep. Derek Kilmer (D-Wash.). "He has inherited the chaos he has sown."