Social media: How 'content' replaced friendship
Facebook has shifted from connecting with friends to competing with entertainment companies

"Social media has become less social," said Kyle Chayka in The New Yorker. In its heyday, "Facebook was where you might find out that your friend was dating someone new, or that someone had thrown a party without inviting you." But today's version of social media is "where we find promotional videos created by celebrities, pundits shouting responses to the news," and a "rising tide of AI-generated slop." Federal regulators are currently suing Meta over its monopoly on "personal social networking services." The government's case, though, relies on sifting through deals made more than a decade ago, when Facebook was "singular and inescapable." In the age of TikTok and YouTube, that feels antiquated.
Meta CEO Mark Zuckerberg recently testified that his company is now really in the "discovery-entertainment space," and he's not wrong, said Issie Lapowsky in Vanity Fair. Zuckerberg has a lot of incentive to say that he's competing with the whole world of entertainment companies. That "undermines a central pillar" of the antitrust case he faces. But the numbers do bear him out. He testified that "just 20 percent of the content people consume on Facebook and 10 percent of content they see on Instagram is from their friends." It's highly debatable whether this evolution has been good for users, "but from a legal standpoint," in this case, it's good for Meta. Technology has changed so much that the trial has felt like "a trip down memory lane," said Mike Isaac and Cecilia Kang in The New York Times. Zuckerberg "winced as he watched his younger self on video discuss some of his early competitive concerns," including Dropbox. Other apps that used to worry Zuckerberg included Path, Orkut, Evernote, and Google Plus— all dead or obsolete. Even the version of Facebook that the government is trying to depict sounds extinct. To the government, it's "about connecting with friends and family." That's the Facebook of a decade ago, "a long time in internet years."
It's not clear that Zuckerberg wants the evolution of social media to unfold this way, said Shira Ovide in The Washington Post. He seems oddly envious of his own app, Instagram, which he has sometimes treated "more like a rival than a successful part of his own company." In 2018, he "considered casting off Instagram" because he was worried its growth "could hurt the Facebook app." He waffled over whether to announce when Instagram reached 1 billion users. According to psychologist Abraham Tesser, Zuckerberg built the original Facebook and still treats it "as an extension of himself." Like a jealous lover, he resents the popularity of something new. But he's probably got to stop living in the past.
Subscribe to The Week
Escape your echo chamber. Get the facts behind the news, plus analysis from multiple perspectives.

Sign up for The Week's Free Newsletters
From our morning news briefing to a weekly Good News Newsletter, get the best of The Week delivered directly to your inbox.
From our morning news briefing to a weekly Good News Newsletter, get the best of The Week delivered directly to your inbox.
A free daily email with the biggest news stories of the day – and the best features from TheWeek.com
-
July 27 editorial cartoons
Cartoons Today's political cartoons include tough stains, heatwaves, and vote-losing behaviour
-
5 attention-grabbing cartoons about Trump's distraction tactics
Cartoons Artists take on a musical diversion, an NFL team by any other name, and more
-
The Coldplay affair: a cautionary tale
In the Spotlight The pair became 'the most googled people on the planet' after getting caught having an affair at a Coldplay concert
-
Palantir: The all-seeing tech giant
Feature Palantir's data-mining tools are used by spies and the military. Are they now being turned on Americans?
-
Intellectual property: AI gains at creators' expense
Feature Two federal judges ruled that it is fair use for AI firms to use copyrighted media to train bots
-
What's Linda Yaccarino's legacy? And what's next for X?
Today's Big Question An 'uncertain future' in the age of TikTok
-
The first AI job cuts are already here
Feature Companies are removing entry-level jobs as AI takes over
-
The god in the machine
Feature An AI model with superhuman intelligence could soon become reality. Should we be worried?
-
Unreal: A quantum leap in AI video
Feature Google's new Veo 3 is making it harder to distinguish between real videos and AI-generated ones
-
Will 2027 be the year of the AI apocalypse?
In The Spotlight A 'scary and vivid' new forecast predicts that artificial superintelligence is on the horizon
-
Learning loss: AI cheating upends education
Feature Teachers are questioning the future of education as students turn to AI for help with their assignments