Should England give the World Cup to New Zealand?
Australian umpire claims scoring error in the dramatic final over could have changed the outcome
England’s director of cricket Ashley Giles has brushed off claims that England’s stunning World Cup victory came from an umpiring error.
As BBC Sport reports, the hosts were awarded six vital runs in the 50th over when a throw from a Kiwi fielder hit the bat of Ben Stokes as he dived to complete a second run and went for four.
The freak incident was crucial as England tied with New Zealand to send the game into a super over but TV replays show that Stokes and Adil Rashid hadn’t crossed when fielder Martin Guptill released the ball. So should England have been awarded five runs rather than six?
Subscribe to The Week
Escape your echo chamber. Get the facts behind the news, plus analysis from multiple perspectives.
Sign up for The Week's Free Newsletters
From our morning news briefing to a weekly Good News Newsletter, get the best of The Week delivered directly to your inbox.
From our morning news briefing to a weekly Good News Newsletter, get the best of The Week delivered directly to your inbox.
Retired Australian umpire Simon Taufel, voted the International Cricket Council’s Umpire of the Year on five occasions , drew the world’s attention to the error, citing law 19.8 regarding an “overthrow or wilful act of fielder”. He told the Australian media the six runs awarded to England was a “clear mistake”. He added: “There was a judgment error on the overthrow. The act of the overthrow starts when the fielder releases the ball. It becomes an overthrow from the instant of the throw.”
The disgruntled New Zealand Herald weighed in on the controversy, writing: “To add to New Zealand’s sense of injustice, had this been spotted at the time, Rashid would have been on strike for the penultimate delivery rather than Stokes, further diminishing the chances of England completing a famous victory.”
Giles, however, gave the idea that the Kiwis had been robbed of the title short shrift. “Not really,” he replied, when asked if he understood the uproar. “You could argue the last ball that [Trent] Boult bowled was a full toss on leg stump and if Stokes’ hadn’t just been looking for two he probably would’ve banged it out of the ground anyway. We are world champions; we have got the trophy and we intend to keep it.”
While the Kiwi press may be whining about the World Cup defeat, their players have acted with more dignity. “It doesn’t mean anything to us now,” Henry Nicholls told BBC Radio 5 Live. “It’s the game, things happen. Sometimes you get the rub of the green. England had a great tournament, they have been the dominant team for the last four years so they deserve to win it.”
Coach Gary Stead echoed those sentiments, saying: “The umpires are there to rule and they’re human as well, like players, sometimes errors are made,” rationalised Stead. “That’s just the human nature of sport, and why we care so much about it as well.”
And of course there is always more than one side to a story. Some argue that the ‘act’ of the overthrows actually began when the ball struck Stokes’ bat, deflecting the ball to the boundary, not when the throw was released.
Sign up for Today's Best Articles in your inbox
A free daily email with the biggest news stories of the day – and the best features from TheWeek.com
-
7 beautiful towns to visit in Switzerland during the holidays
The Week Recommends Find bliss in these charming Swiss locales that blend the traditional with the modern
By Catherine Garcia, The Week US Published
-
The Week contest: Werewolf bill
Puzzles and Quizzes
By The Week US Published
-
'This needs to be a bigger deal'
Instant Opinion Opinion, comment and editorials of the day
By Justin Klawans, The Week US Published
-
What's wrong with Pakistan's cricket team?
Under the Radar Dramatic downfall of previous powerhouse blamed on poor management and appointments of regime favourites at governing body PCB
By Harriet Marsden, The Week UK Published
-
Cricket is swiftly becoming America's new obsession
In the Spotlight Team USA recently shocked the world by beating Pakistan in the Men's World Cup
By Justin Klawans, The Week US Published
-
'Drunken hooligans': America's cricket fears
Why Everyone's Talking About South Asian community 'energised' by sport's growing popularity in US but some locals oppose new stadiums
By Chas Newkey-Burden, The Week UK Published
-
Ben Stokes and England set up a ‘grand finale’ against South Africa
feature In an old-school Test victory at Old Trafford, England’s captain scored a century and took four crucial wickets
By The Week Staff Published
-
‘Alarm bells’ for authorities: is there too much cricket being played?
Talking Point Ben Stokes quitting one-day internationals has sparked a debate over the packed schedule
By Mike Starling Published
-
England cricket: the Ben Stokes era gets off to a ‘perfect’ start
feature Ex-skipper Joe Root was a ‘totem of strength’ in Test win over New Zealand at Lord’s
By The Week Staff Published
-
Ben Stokes: England’s new Test cricket captain sets out his stall
feature Stokes’s spectacular innings – his first since being appointed England skipper – bodes well
By The Week Staff Published
-
Ben Stokes: from the ‘Bristol incident’ to England’s Test captaincy
Why Everyone’s Talking About Durham all-rounder has been confirmed as Joe Root’s replacement
By Mike Starling Published