Opinion Brief

Obama's primetime debt ceiling address: 4 takeaways

The president spoke to the nation Monday night, just a week before the U.S. may run out of money to pay many of its bills. What did we learn?

President Obama gave a 15-minute speech on the debt-ceiling stalemate on Monday night, warning of the economic pain for the U.S. economy and American families if Congress doesn't raise the nation's legal borrowing limit by Aug. 2. House Speaker John Boehner (R-Ohio), who pulled out of White House negotiations late last week, gave a five-minute rebuttal directly afterward, blaming the impasse on Obama's insistence on a "balanced" plan that cuts spending and raises revenue. What did the dueling speeches tell us about where we are in this dangerous standoff? Here, four takeaways:

1. Obama is hewing to the center; Boehner keeps tacking rightIf anything was clarified in the back-to-back speeches, it's that "the debate over the debt ceiling is not left vs. right," says E.J. Dionne in The Washington Post. "It's center vs. right," and Obama has placed himself firmly on the side of "middle-of-the-road Americans." Obama backed a Senate plan that takes a meat cleaver to federal spending, in a speech with some "nice touches" — like a surprisingly apt Ronald Reagan quote, and a useful reminder that free-spending Republicans didn't "worry about deficits until Obama took office." Boehner, meanwhile, spoke mainly to his conservative base, and made crystal clear that the GOP is "committed to low taxes for the wealthy above everything else," including America's creditworthiness. 

2. The president still has no planA week away from default, "the president has yet to bring a plan of his own to the table, instead relying on others to address the looming fiscal crisis," says S.E. Cupp in the New York Daily News. Obama has given speeches, engaged in political gamesmanship, and "petulantly scolded House and Senate Republicans." What he needs to do is lead. Boehner, on the other hand, does have a specific plan, says Nate Silver in The New York Times. But the speaker's politically charged proposal is a non-starter in the Senate, and may not even pass in Boehner's House.

3. Obama has given up on RepublicansObama's "pitch-perfect 15-minute address" was actually very effective at getting across "the real dangers of failing to raise the U.S. debt ceiling," says Richard Adams in Britain's Guardian. But based on his hard words for GOP legislators, it's pretty clear that "Obama must now assume that his chances of genuine cooperation have vanished, if they were ever there in the first place." It's unlikely that shaming House Republicans will win him any votes for the Senate measure he favors, but who knows? "It worked for Harry Truman and FDR."

4. We won't get a solution until the last minute... if at allObama and Boehner both interrupted "America's primetime TV lineup" mainly to "posture in public for political advantage," says Michael Scherer in TIME. That's frustrating, but it at least gave the viewing public a clear picture of the gap dividing the two sides of this absurd threat to the U.S. and global economy. So we're left with a few "more nail-biting days" of test votes and secret negotiations, says Dan Balz in The Washington Post. Then, "only when it is shown that neither Boehner's nor [Senate Majority Leader Harry] Reid's plan can get out of Congress can real negotiations for a compromise begin." Let's hope it's not too late.

Recommended

Cawthorn's anti-abortion comments spark outrage
madison cawthorn
Getting into the Word

Cawthorn's anti-abortion comments spark outrage

Polls close in first Gambian presidential election since dictator's exile
Gambian election
Plonk! goes your vote

Polls close in first Gambian presidential election since dictator's exile

Le Pen, Orban, and other European populist leaders meet in Warsaw
Orban and Le Pen
to the right now, y'all

Le Pen, Orban, and other European populist leaders meet in Warsaw

Democrats' role in the looming loss of abortion rights
A donkey.
Picture of Ryan CooperRyan Cooper

Democrats' role in the looming loss of abortion rights

Most Popular

Late night hosts joke about Trump's secret COVID test
Donald Trump shares COVID with Joe Biden
Last Night on Late Night

Late night hosts joke about Trump's secret COVID test

Meghan Markle handed win in court battle with U.K. tabloid
Meghan Markle
meghan vs. tabloids

Meghan Markle handed win in court battle with U.K. tabloid

Fox News personality Lara Logan condemned for likening Fauci to Nazi doctor
Lara Logan.
wow

Fox News personality Lara Logan condemned for likening Fauci to Nazi doctor