By the numbers

Justice Clarence Thomas's 5-year silence: By the numbers

The conservative Supreme Court justice is making history by staying speechless for so long. Here's how his silent streak breaks down

The Supreme Court's return from its midwinter break next week will mark a legal milestone: It will have been five years since Justice Clarence Thomas last spoke during a court argument, a record unequalled by any other justice in recent decades. His "epic silence on the bench is just one part of his enigmatic and contradictory persona," says Adam Liptak in The New York Times. Here, a brief guide, by the numbers, to Justice Thomas's silent years:

5
Number of years, as of next Tuesday, since Justice Thomas last spoke during a court argument. "While Thomas's silence on the bench may be regrettable, there's no question he's taking a very active part in the justices' internal debates," says Damon W. Root in Reason. "And that, after all, is where the court's decisions are ultimately made."

40
Number of years since any other justice has gone an entire term, let alone five, without speaking, according to Timothy R. Johnson, a University of Minnesota political science professor

133
Average number of questions per hourlong argument that Supreme Court justices collectively asked from 1988 to 2008. That's more than two questions per minute. "Thomas isn't wrong to suggest that the last thing the bench needs is another chatterbox," says Dahlia Lithwick at Slate.

100
Average number of questions per hourlong argument asked by Supreme Court justices from 1972 to 1987. "The post-Scalia court, from 1986 onward, has become a much more talkative bench," says Professor Johnson.

Nearly 1 out of 5
Number of questions from the bench that have come from Justice Antonin Scalia in the last 20 years. "Thomas's ultraconservative ideological court soul mate Antonin Scalia is the most verbose [justice]," says Earl Ofari Hutchinson at Thy Black Man.

12
Number of times Justice Thomas spoke in the 2005-2006 term, before beginning his silent streak. His last question was on a death penalty case on February 22, 2006. "His few questions were typically pithy and pointed," says Adam Liptak in The New York Times.

11
Number of times Justice Thomas spoke in the 2004-2005 term.

No less than 5
Number of explanations Thomas has offered for his silence. They include: 1) Being self-conscious about his accent; 2) Feeling that the bench already asks enough questions; 3) Thinking that another justice will inevitably ask any question he might pose; 4) Believing that he learns more by listening than by talking; and 5) Feeling that it's "counterproductive" to interrupt lawyers in the middle of their arguments.

Sources: New York Times (2)(3), Reason, Thy Black Man, Slate, Bloomberg, Death and Taxes, PR Newswire

Recommended

Biden announces relocation funding for native tribes impacted by climate change
Biden at Tribal Nations Summit
Higher ground

Biden announces relocation funding for native tribes impacted by climate change

IRS hands Trump's federal tax returns over to House committee
Donald Trump.
access granted

IRS hands Trump's federal tax returns over to House committee

ISIS confirms its leader was killed, does not provide details
A militant is seen holding the flag of ISIS in 2015.
Another One Gone

ISIS confirms its leader was killed, does not provide details

Jeffries chosen to succeed Pelosi as leader of House Dems
Hakeem Jeffries.
Ch-ch-ch-ch-changes

Jeffries chosen to succeed Pelosi as leader of House Dems

Most Popular

World's 1st hydrogen-powered jet engine could mark turning point for aviation industry
A Rolls-Royce engine seen during an airshow.
Flying High

World's 1st hydrogen-powered jet engine could mark turning point for aviation industry

Everything to know about the storm poised to pummel the South
Tornado
Storm Watch

Everything to know about the storm poised to pummel the South

Why did Merrick Garland appoint a special counsel to investigate Trump?
Trump, Garland, and Smith.
Briefing

Why did Merrick Garland appoint a special counsel to investigate Trump?