Opinion

What House of Cards gets exactly right about political journalism

The shady coziness of reporters and politicians is all too real

There is no one who loves politics as much as I do. And yet, somehow I didn't start watching the Netflix series House of Cards until more than two years after the first episode came out.

I intended to watch. Really. But frankly, I was put off by the severe criticism from many political journalists — people whose opinions I really respect — who thought the show was unrealistic. Much of their disapproval was about the way reporters are portrayed in the show.

A quick sampling:

Chris Cillizza of The Washington Post: "Let's start with the fact that the way Zoe, a young reporter, begins her source building with Underwood is by going to his house late one night to show him a picture of him looking at her butt on the way into an event. That seems both far-fetched and, frankly, offensive to female reporters everywhere."

Maureen Ryan of The Huffington Post: "Just once, for the love of God, I'd like someone who knows how print and digital operations actually work to write scenes that make them seem interesting and fresh, and that don't involve female co-workers who are unable to resist petty catfights."

Allysa Rosenberg of Slate: "I know the show has no interest in getting this profession right."

After reading these reviews, I had little interest in dedicating the 13 hours or so it would take to watch the first season. After all, who has that kind of time to waste?

However, on a recent eight-hour flight home from Europe, I finally succumbed. I binge-watched five episodes in a row. And guess what? I really enjoyed the show, and discovered that the criticism was unfair. The series actually shines a much-needed bright light on some of the big problems with political journalism.

House of Cards doesn't really portray anyone — politicians, lobbyists, reporters — in a particularly good light. The main character, Frank Underwood (played by Kevin Spacey), isn't just a slimy and unethical politician. He's actually evil.

But by taking each of the characters in the show to their extremes, House of Cards does a pretty good job of highlighting what's wrong with much of our political culture. And that includes political journalism.

Most reporters don't sleep with politicians to get their stories as they do in House of Cards. Nonetheless, many political reporters are way too close to the people they are supposed to be covering. And that often impedes their judgment in ways that are harmful to their profession.

Most real-world journalists might not be as unethical as they are in House of Cards, but there are many who are more interested in ambition and power than they are in getting to the truth of a story.

This point was driven home by the recent White House Correspondents' Dinner, where journalists, politicians, and celebrities — including some of the actors in House of Cards itself — mingled while listening to jokes about themselves. It's a wildly popular evening in Washington, D.C., and many make a weekend of it with pre-parties, after-parties, and brunches the next morning.

But how many journalists are willing to write a critical story about a congressman or senator after a weekend of socializing together?

The dinner has become a symbol of all that is wrong with the intersection of politics and journalism. Politicians and reporters may not sleep together after the dinner — well, not all of them at least — but many are way too cozy with each other to do their jobs well.

That's the point that I think House of Cards is trying to make about political journalism. And it's absolutely right.

More From...

Picture of Taegan GoddardTaegan Goddard
Read All
Yes, Hillary Clinton is running for president
Hillary Clinton
Taegan Goddard

Yes, Hillary Clinton is running for president

The end of Iowa's outsized political power?
Huckabee
Analysis

The end of Iowa's outsized political power?

How technology is destroying American democracy
Barack Obama
Opinion

How technology is destroying American democracy

The GOP's three-wing circus: Can any candidate unite them all?
Circus Tent
Opinion

The GOP's three-wing circus: Can any candidate unite them all?

Recommended

Jeffries chosen to succeed Pelosi as leader of House Dems
Hakeem Jeffries.
Ch-ch-ch-ch-changes

Jeffries chosen to succeed Pelosi as leader of House Dems

The conservatives who have turned on Trump
Donald Trump.
Briefing

The conservatives who have turned on Trump

Which actors will win an Oscar in 2023?
Oscar contenders.
Briefing

Which actors will win an Oscar in 2023?

GOP leader Kevin McCarthy's bid for House speaker may really be in peril
Kevin McCarthy
You don't have the votes

GOP leader Kevin McCarthy's bid for House speaker may really be in peril

Most Popular

World's 1st hydrogen-powered jet engine could mark turning point for aviation industry
A Rolls-Royce engine seen during an airshow.
Flying High

World's 1st hydrogen-powered jet engine could mark turning point for aviation industry

Sanctions apparently hurting Russia's economy, Ukraine war effort
Vladimir Putin
New Pain no gain

Sanctions apparently hurting Russia's economy, Ukraine war effort

China's Xi has few good options amid protests of 'zero COVID' policy
Anti-zero COVID protest in Beijing
China's COVID protests

China's Xi has few good options amid protests of 'zero COVID' policy