Opinion

Finding the humor in Melania's plagiarism blunder

Perhaps the best thing about Melania's instance of borrowed words was the avalanche of hilarious, quick-witted reactions that followed

In between harsh rhetorical broadsides against President Obama and his former secretary of state, Hillary Clinton, at Monday night's Republican National Convention, Donald Trump's wife, Melania Trump, stepped in with a refreshingly positive speech about herself and her husband. It was a good speech, introduced rockstar-style by Donald Trump himself, a clear highlight of the evening matched only perhaps by former New York Mayor Rudy Giuliani's impassioned attack on Clinton and President Obama.

But Melania Trump's speech, which she claimed to have written most of, quickly went from asset to liability, when people started noticing curious similarities between her language and the speech Michelle Obama gave in 2008 while introducing her husband, soon-to-be-President Obama.

The apparent plagiarism doesn't sound much better in stereo:

Melania's speech quickly became the news of the night, and not in a way that reflects very positively on Donald Trump's campaign:

The cryptic response from the Trump campaign only added fuel to the already raging dumpster fire.

Plagiarism is a serious accusation, and it can severely cripple political aspirations — just ask Joe Biden. This may not be the first time Melania Trump borrowed heavily from a black woman, either. But Melania isn't a politician. So what are we to do with this pretty egregious, high-profile example of cut-and-paste speechwriting?

Some observers, like The New Republic's Brian Beutler, argue that we shouldn't just laugh off the wife of the presumptive Republican presidential nominee lifting whole lines from the speech of the wife of the president said nominee routinely criticizes as incompetent and worse.

The apparent plagiarism — which Beutler says he suspects Melania was not aware of — amplifies the charge that Trump is "sloppy, erratic, in so many ways the opposite of the virtues he claims to embody," he says, but is also "a depiction of a campaign that nurtures white grievance and resentment trying to profit off the work of a black woman, from an African-American family that Trump and his supporters regularly belittle." The Week's Marc Ambinder hits a similar theme.

All of this may be true, but the idea of Melania Trump plagiarizing Michelle Obama also has a decidedly humorous element to it. Twitter on Monday night and early Tuesday morning was a virtual comedy club, with pundits of all stripes trying out their comedy chops:

But perhaps the funniest reaction is an apparently sincere appreciation of Melania's speech from a Trump supporter with the Twitter name Inductivist:

Of course, laughter and outrage are two sides of the same coin, with laughter the more attractive one. There's room for both responses. And Mrs. Trump does have her defenders, including former spelling-based game show host Chuck Woolery:

"Deference," Chuck? Sometimes the jokes really do write themselves.

More From...

Picture of Peter WeberPeter Weber
Read All
The Daily Show mocks Fox News' 'No Sedition Charges' Jan. 6 talking point
The Daily Show on the death of a meme
RIP talking point

The Daily Show mocks Fox News' 'No Sedition Charges' Jan. 6 talking point

China's COVID lockdowns trapped woman at blind date's house
Lockdown in China's Henan province
No joke

China's COVID lockdowns trapped woman at blind date's house

Texas attorney general ordered to release emails, texts from Jan. 6 Capitol attack
Ken Paxton, Donald Trump
Sunlight is a fine disinfectant

Texas attorney general ordered to release emails, texts from Jan. 6 Capitol attack

Late night hosts cheer Oath Keepers, Prince Andrew facing real consequences
Stephen Colbert
Last Night on Late Night

Late night hosts cheer Oath Keepers, Prince Andrew facing real consequences

Recommended

Ukraine blames Russia for cyberattack
Ukrainian military drill
virtual warfare

Ukraine blames Russia for cyberattack

Trump mocks and criticizes Biden at rally in Arizona
Donald Trump
Trump 2024?

Trump mocks and criticizes Biden at rally in Arizona

Djokovic forced to leave Australia after court upholds visa cancellation
Novak Djokovic
game, set, match

Djokovic forced to leave Australia after court upholds visa cancellation

Youngkin eliminates cabinet-level DEI post
Glenn Youngkin
bye bye to dei

Youngkin eliminates cabinet-level DEI post

Most Popular

Will 2022 bring another Miracle on Ice?
The Miracle on Ice.
Samuel Goldman

Will 2022 bring another Miracle on Ice?

Omicron may be headed for a sharp drop because so many people are infected
Dr. Janet Woodcock
Omicron Blues

Omicron may be headed for a sharp drop because so many people are infected

California deputy DA opposed to vaccine mandates dies of COVID-19
Kelly Ernby.
covid-19

California deputy DA opposed to vaccine mandates dies of COVID-19