Opinion

How Alexis de Tocqueville predicted the alt-right — almost 200 years ago

He warned us that democracy can turn against freedom

Alexis de Tocqueville warned us that democracy can turn against freedom.

The public/private divide that long grounded our consensus liberal regime has begun to be replaced. In the public and private sector alike, the new regime is busily effacing the old boundary that separated regulated thoughts and actions from unregulated ones. Think of today's battles over who gets to use what restroom, how harmful free speech can be, or what sort of political symbolism creates an officially hostile work environment.

There is a very clear boundary between prescribed virtue and proscribed vice. Indeed, the health and safety police need that boundary to police, even if they have to prove that it keeps creeping forward with ever smaller steps. Inside the boundary, life is kept rigorously rational, scripted, risk-averse, sanitized, clean, and secure. But there will always be a misfit remnant beyond the gates, impulsive, unscripted, risk-begging, filthy, coarse, and dangerous.

Ladies and gentlemen, this is the alt-right.

Indeed, much of the alt-right, the neo-reactionaries, and the rest of today's new political movement arose predictably from the wilds of enforced culture's no-go zones, where today's seemingly universal health-and-safety police could not or would not patrol. Are they at war with liberalism? Sure. But at root, they're even more dedicated to defeating the post-liberal regime that has come to replace it — the regime that makes a supreme virtue of progressively regulating health and safety.

And Tocqueville predicted it. He noted that equality in servitude would hold secret charms for weak and isolated people whose experience of individualism was of struggling for distinction among millions just like them, clamoring for the same few goals. But at the same time, he cautioned that the same boundary police they'd be apt to turn to for relief would also wound their pride. The meddling of officialdom in the details of everyday life actually makes us feel small and powerless, even when it's to our own benefit. And for the officials doing the meddling, coarse people tend to seem deplorably incapable of running their own lives in healthy and safe enough fashion.

In this climate, Tocqueville observed, sharp economic inequalities could arise from the general deepening of equality in habits and mores. So instead of a war between haves and have nots, we have a powerful officialdom that unites the super-rich and the poor in a coalition around the expert production, broad distribution, and progressive advancement of health and safety. The clear implication of Tocqueville's ruminations on the intersection of individual weakness, official invasiveness, collective resentment, and fear of the cultural wilds was that the new center of gravity for political opposition to officialdom would arise from those most comfortable with risk, dirtiness, danger — with everything a strict nurse or Human Resources manager would disapprove of.

Enter Pepe. Enter Trump. Enter the Deplorables. Here is a constituency that loves more than anything to fling its filthy goo into the face of those for whom unofficial vice is an existential terror.

The task now facing the GOP is daunting: to return a constructive culture of natural risk to the political mainstream, transcending the false choice between official virtue and unofficial vice. Even more daunting, Tocqueville suggests that all national politics can do is try to focus the public imagination on goals that draw us together without rancor. Good luck with that.

More From...

Picture of James PoulosJames Poulos
Read All
If Trump goes down, everyone wins
President Trump.
Opinion

If Trump goes down, everyone wins

China's digital nightmare
Xi Jinping.
Analysis

China's digital nightmare

America's failure in Afghanistan is going to be worse than Vietnam
U.S. troops outside their base in Uruzgan province, Afghanistan.
Opinion

America's failure in Afghanistan is going to be worse than Vietnam

The hard truths of Mosul's 'liberation'
An Iraqi Federal police officer walks among the ruins in Mosul.
Opinion

The hard truths of Mosul's 'liberation'

Recommended

Texas is gearing up for Attorney General Ken Paxton's summer impeachment trial
Ken Paxton
Non Sine Die

Texas is gearing up for Attorney General Ken Paxton's summer impeachment trial

Biden's reelection calculus
President Joe Biden
Briefing

Biden's reelection calculus

The risks and rewards of retail politics
Florida Gov. Ron DeSantis in New Hampshire
Behind the scenes

The risks and rewards of retail politics

What's in Biden and McCarthy's deal to suspend the debt limit
Kevin McCarthy
Art of the Deal

What's in Biden and McCarthy's deal to suspend the debt limit

Most Popular

Disney hits back against DeSantis
Entranceway to Walt Disney World.
Feature

Disney hits back against DeSantis

What the shifting religious landscape means for American politics
Ballot box
Talking point

What the shifting religious landscape means for American politics

South Korean man facing prison time after opening airplane door in midair
An Asiana Airlines flight that had its emergency door opened midair.
Problems in the Sky

South Korean man facing prison time after opening airplane door in midair