Opinion

What happens if Trump fires Mueller?

Would giving Mueller the axe change anything? Or would congressional Republicans continue to look away?

President Trump has spent his tenure in office shattering norms of presidential conduct, and his disdain for legal restraints may be about to reach another level. The possibility that Trump will fire Special Counsel Robert Mueller is becoming very real, and there's no doubt that, at the very least, Trump is actively trying to undermine Mueller's investigation. The fact that an unprecedentedly corrupt president is interfering with a critical investigation into his own financial practices and his campaign's apparent collusion with Russia in the 2016 elections constitutes a major threat to the rule of law. But we should remember that the Constitution provides a remedy that could address Trump's lawlessness. The problem is that congressional Republicans are abdicating their oversight responsibilities for partisan reasons.

The threat that Trump might fire Muller is clear. In a remarkable interview with The New York Times last week, Trump said that "a special counsel should never have been appointed." More strikingly, he said that if Attorney General Jeff Sessions "was going to recuse himself, he should have told me before he took the job, and I would have picked somebody else." The belief that the attorney general owes personal loyalty to the president demonstrates the difference between a president who respects the rule of law and one who does not. And given that Trump has already fired FBI Director James Comey to obstruct the investigation into Russia's electoral interference, it's not a huge stretch to think that Mueller might be next.

And despite the (not actually true) cliché that "it's the coverup, not the crime," it's nearly certain that Trump is engaging in a coverup because he's guilty of serious wrongdoing. It's telling that Trump's most strenuous objections have come after Mueller's team started to look into Trump's financial transactions. There's a reason Trump violated longstanding norms by refusing to release his tax returns, and it's certainly not because he has nothing to hide.

So we have a president who may well be guilty of serious offenses, and these offenses may have involved colluding with a foreign power's interference into an election. And yet, Trump can probably fire Mueller and get away with it, at least in the short term. How?

In some respects, America's Constitution might allow Trump to evade accountability. The American people saw enough problems with Trump to reject him at the ballot box, but the Electoral College installed the popular vote loser. And one prominent mechanism that can now allow Trump and his associates to evade punishment is also in the Constitution. While there's serious question about whether Trump can pardon himself, the president is right that he has an absolute power to pardon anyone, and he can pre-emptively pardon anyone who might be implicated in illegal activity on behalf of Trump himself.

But the Constitution does have one remedy: the impeachment power. Trump would be much less likely to fire Mueller if there was a credible threat to remove Trump from office. Nixon's decision to fire Special Prosecutor Archibald Cox helped create a bipartisan consensus that Nixon had committed impeachable offenses. When Nixon was told that support among Senate Republicans was collapsing, he pre-emptively resigned. If the Republican congressional leadership made it clear that firing Mueller was unacceptable, Trump might be dissuaded, and if he went ahead anyway he could potentially be held accountable at an impeachment trial.

But all indications remain that Republicans will do no such thing. After all, evidence of Trump's corruption was clear before the election, and his disregarding of norms and use of the office for his own material benefit has, if anything, exceeded the fears of his critics. And yet, congressional Republicans have been notably unwilling to exercise their oversight authority. There's an implicit deal: Getting Republican-nominated judicial and executive branch appointments confirmed and a Republican signature for legislation that a Republican Congress can pass means that Trump can be as corrupt as he wants.

Would firing Muller change anything? Almost certainly not. Republican members of Congress might ritually express that they're "troubled" or "concerned," but they will almost certainly then do nothing while Trump continues to undermine the rule of law.

Assuming Trump fires Mueller, and Republicans continue to look away, can anything be done? Maybe. Mueller is almost certainly documenting his findings, and will have information to provide if called to testify by the current or future Congress. It's also possible that state attorneys general, most notably New York's Eric Schneiderman, could continue investigations into Trump's finances if he does fire Mueller.

Still, not one of these alternatives is fully satisfactory. The rule of law is under threat because Republicans are putting their extremely unpopular policy agenda ahead of the interests of the country. Ultimately, the remedy for Trump's misconduct might have to come from the ballot box.

More From...

Picture of Scott LemieuxScott Lemieux
Read All
The GOP's bad faith SCOTUS diversions
Amy Coney Barrett.
Opinion

The GOP's bad faith SCOTUS diversions

Stop assuming voters won't care about Trump's taxes
President Trump.
Analysis

Stop assuming voters won't care about Trump's taxes

The long, slow death of the Affordable Care Act
The Supreme Court.
Analysis

The long, slow death of the Affordable Care Act

Stand by your man?
Kavanaugh, McConnell, and Pence
Analysis

Stand by your man?

Recommended

The Nicki Minaj-Tucker Carlson connection
Nicki Minaj and Tucker Carlson.
Picture of W. James Antle IIIW. James Antle III

The Nicki Minaj-Tucker Carlson connection

Schwarzenegger says recall mess has sunk California GOP from box office flop to 'direct-to-video'
Arnold Schwarzenegger
California Recall Election

Schwarzenegger says recall mess has sunk California GOP from box office flop to 'direct-to-video'

The insanity of leaving Africa unvaccinated
A protestor.
Picture of Ryan CooperRyan Cooper

The insanity of leaving Africa unvaccinated

A tax reckoning for the left
President Biden and AOC.
Picture of James PethokoukisJames Pethokoukis

A tax reckoning for the left

Most Popular

Emmys host Cedric the Entertainer hoping 'not to get canceled'
Leon Bennett/Getty Images
'what have I done in the last three months'

Emmys host Cedric the Entertainer hoping 'not to get canceled'

How Newsom ran away with the recall
Gavin Newsom.
Picture of David FarisDavid Faris

How Newsom ran away with the recall

Lindsey Graham boosts Afghanistan's anti-Taliban resistance behind the scenes
Lindsey Graham.
get the word out

Lindsey Graham boosts Afghanistan's anti-Taliban resistance behind the scenes