Opinion

Don't be fooled by Trump's manufactured voter-fraud crisis

We've heard this all before

If Democrats manage to take one or both houses of Congress as the result of the midterm elections, you can be fairly certain President Trump will respond to the setback in classic Trump fashion: He will manufacture a crisis.

He was laying the groundwork for this on Monday, the last day before the election, warning of voter fraud in his tweets and at every stop on the campaign trail.

"Law Enforcement has been strongly notified to watch closely for any ILLEGAL VOTING which may take place in Tuesday's Election (or Early Voting)," he tweeted Monday.

In Cleveland, he told reporters: "Just take a look. All you have to do is go around, take a look at what's happened over the years, and you'll see. There are a lot of people — a lot of people — my opinion, and based on proof, that try and get in illegally and actually vote illegally. So we just want to let them know that there will be prosecutions at the highest level."

The problem with Trump's assertions about illegal voting is that there is no evidence of widespread voter fraud in the United States. You could be fooled for thinking otherwise, after years of digging and wild claims by Republicans who, for some reason, can never simply admit they took a good licking in an election. Trump's fraud, it turns out, is a fraud itself.

We've been down this road before. During the final days of the 2016 presidential campaign, when it appeared that Hillary Clinton was going to win the election, Trump began warning against the widespread voter fraud that he expected would "rob" him of his rightful victory. Trump, it appeared at the time, was prepared to respond to defeat with a wholly manufactured crisis of legitimacy. He even warned he might not accept the election results.

Then he won. But his unexpected victory didn't quite put an end to his conspiracy-mongering. While Trump won the Electoral College, he lost the popular vote — and that seemed to stick in his craw. He asserted repeatedly that this was because millions of people voted illegally for Clinton. There was no evidence to support this claim. He even appointed a "Presidential Advisory Commission on Election Integrity" to search for evidence of such fraud. It found nothing.

At the same time, Trump's own legitimacy in office came under scrutiny. Questions about his campaign's contact with Russia, which were nascent during the campaign, exploded into full view around the time of his inauguration, and culminated in the appointment of Robert Mueller as special counsel to investigate the events of the 2016 campaign.

Trump's allies suggested the special counsel investigation was evidence of hypocrisy: Trump's critics were angry when he questioned the legitimacy of a Clinton election, they said, yet were perfectly happy to undermine Trump. "Now liberals are singing a different tune," wrote one observer at National Review.

The big difference between Trump's accusations of voter fraud and the allegations of corruption surrounding his campaign is that there is some evidence to support the latter. We know from emails that Trump's son was willing to meet with Russians to dig up dirt on Clinton. We known that Facebook and Twitter were manipulated by Russian hackers in 2016. And Trump's own supine behavior when meeting with Russian President Vladimir Putin invited its own conjecture.

Meanwhile, there still remains virtually no evidence of voter fraud. There were four examples of such fraud discovered in 2016 — that's not enough votes to turn the tide in a local dogcatcher election, much less a campaign for president of the United States.

Trump, of course, is just continuing a longstanding Republican tradition. If you listened to Fox News in 2008, you'd be forgiven for believing that Barack Obama's presidential victory was due almost entirely to a few Black Panthers who stood menacingly outside a single Philadelphia polling station that year. That bit of nonsense was so effective that Georgia GOP gubernatorial candidate Brian Kemp revived it this year for his race against his Democratic opponent, Stacey Abrams, who is African American.

But Trump now has the federal government at his full disposal — and, in Jeff Sessions, an attorney general apparently willing to follow the president's muse with official investigations. "Fraud in the voting process will not be tolerated," Sessions warned on Monday.

I repeat: There is no evidence that voter fraud exists, at least not to any significant degree. There never has been that evidence, and there almost certainly won't be this time around. Trump casts himself as the defender of election integrity, even as he abuses the system and its participants.

More From...

Picture of Joel MathisJoel Mathis
Read All
Why Kevin McCarthy won't be speaker
Kevin McCarthy.
Talking Points

Why Kevin McCarthy won't be speaker

Mississippi's disingenuous anti-abortion argument
Protesters.
Talking Points

Mississippi's disingenuous anti-abortion argument

America won't reconsider its imperial reach
President Biden.
Talking Points

America won't reconsider its imperial reach

Biden is not your attack dog
President Biden.
Talking Points

Biden is not your attack dog

Recommended

Mark Meadows may have waived his Trump executive privilege claims
Mark Meadows
Print and Tell

Mark Meadows may have waived his Trump executive privilege claims

Fauci slams Fox over 'unconscionable' comments comparing him to Nazi doctor
Dr. Anthony Fauci
'completely incorrect in everything she says'

Fauci slams Fox over 'unconscionable' comments comparing him to Nazi doctor

10 things you need to know today: December 3, 2021
Washington
Daily briefing

10 things you need to know today: December 3, 2021

The problem of judicial supremacy
The Supreme Court.
Samuel Goldman

The problem of judicial supremacy

Most Popular

Fox News personality Lara Logan condemned for likening Fauci to Nazi doctor
Lara Logan.
wow

Fox News personality Lara Logan condemned for likening Fauci to Nazi doctor

7 cartoons about Thanksgiving inflation
Political Cartoon.
Feature

7 cartoons about Thanksgiving inflation

Honduras ruling party concedes to leftist Xiomara Castro in presidential election
Xiomara Castro
Señora Presidente

Honduras ruling party concedes to leftist Xiomara Castro in presidential election