The Idol: the worst TV show of the year?
HBO drama has been dismissed as ‘one of the worst programmes ever made’
Critics have panned “The Idol” as “the worst TV show of the year” following its finale.
Sam Levinson, the creator of the HBO drama about a troubled pop singer and her thorny relationship with a cult leader, had predicted that “The Idol” would be “the biggest show of the summer”.
However, many critics saw it quite differently. They have damned it as a “confusing mess”, “grossly oversimplified”, and a “painfully tedious TV non-event” that “maintained a consistent awfulness throughout”.
Subscribe to The Week
Escape your echo chamber. Get the facts behind the news, plus analysis from multiple perspectives.
Sign up for The Week's Free Newsletters
From our morning news briefing to a weekly Good News Newsletter, get the best of The Week delivered directly to your inbox.
From our morning news briefing to a weekly Good News Newsletter, get the best of The Week delivered directly to your inbox.
‘Toe-curlingly naff’
Awarding it just one star out of five, The Telegraph declared it “the worst TV show of the year”. Ed Power wrote that the “toe-curlingly naff” series was a “potential turkey for the ages”. He described Lily-Rose Depp, who played the wannabe pop star, as “vacant”, while Abel Tesfaye, aka The Weeknd, was “atrociously stilted” as the self-help guru.
The Guardian was harsher still. Leila Latif said it was “one of the worst programmes ever made” with “the dampest squib of a finale”. Tesfaye’s performance, said Latif, “should be tried at The Hague”.
The problems with the series “aren’t limited to its gratuitous nudity or juvenile eroticism”, wrote Lovia Gyarkye in The Hollywood Reporter, as it is also “dogged by a thin plot and an incoherent narrative”, with storylines “blithely picked up and discarded”.
There has also been criticism of the series within its own camp. “Even those who worked on the show have panned it”, noted Rolling Stone, with production sources describing it as “shockingly boring” and “worse than I thought it’d be”.
‘Gorgeous looking’
However, wrote Chris Vognar for the same magazine, HBO “has had worse mishaps” and the finale was “neither a bang nor a whimper” but simply “not quite as bad as what preceded it”.
There was also faint praise from Laura Martin in Esquire, who wrote that “some viewers are still convinced” that “somewhere, within the dark, grubby crevices of ‘The Idol’, there was, at one point, a decent series in there”.
More full-hearted praise came from Douglas Greenwood in Vogue, who wrote that the “gorgeous-looking horror show” was “buzzy, brazen television that will do exactly what it set out to do: get people talking”.
Are the detractors being too prudish? “Morally dubious art can be great”, wrote Barry Pierce for i-D in an article hooked to the series. “Sleazy art has an important place in our culture,” he added, so “to treat it as morally indefensible or unworthy of your time or support is to fundamentally misunderstand what art is.”
Perhaps the boldest praise and criticisms were both too strong, argued Alison Herman for Variety. “In the end”, she wrote, the series was “neither as offensive as its detractors claimed” nor as “revolutionary” as Levinson believed.
Create an account with the same email registered to your subscription to unlock access.
Sign up for Today's Best Articles in your inbox
A free daily email with the biggest news stories of the day – and the best features from TheWeek.com
Chas Newkey-Burden has been part of The Week Digital team for more than a decade and a journalist for 25 years, starting out on the irreverent football weekly 90 Minutes, before moving to lifestyle magazines Loaded and Attitude. He was a columnist for The Big Issue and landed a world exclusive with David Beckham that became the weekly magazine’s bestselling issue. He now writes regularly for The Guardian, The Telegraph, The Independent, Metro, FourFourTwo and the i new site. He is also the author of a number of non-fiction books.
-
Why is Bluey such a cultural phenomenon?
In the Spotlight Kids are obsessed — but parents get just as much out of the show, if not more
By Anya Jaremko-Greenwold, The Week US Published
-
Is it actually economical to fly basic economy?
The Explainer Airlines have placed so many restrictions on basic economy, you may wonder if it's even worth the savings anymore
By Becca Stanek, The Week US Published
-
So bad, so good: the best worst movies
The Week Recommends These films are as enjoyable as they are terrible
By Anya Jaremko-Greenwold, The Week US Published
-
Is pop music now too reliant on gossip?
Talking Point Taylor Swift's new album has prompted a flurry of speculation over who she is referring to in her songs
By Richard Windsor, The Week UK Published
-
Pundits are mixed on the real possibility of Alex Garland's 'Civil War'
Talking Point Some say the film's events aren't that far from reality, but others are less convinced
By Justin Klawans, The Week US Published
-
The remarkable comedy of Julio Torres
The Explainer His latest endeavor, "Problemista," continues his peerless artistic run
By Scott Hocker, The Week US Published
-
'Are We Dating the Same Guy?': do Facebook groups harm or help?
Talking Point Women share their relationship experiences to try to stay safe on dating apps but critics highlight legal and emotional issues
By Harriet Marsden, The Week UK Published
-
'Not cross buns': the row over recipe revamps
Talking Point New versions of the Easter favourite have sparked controversy but sales are soaring
By Adrienne Wyper, The Week UK Published
-
The art world and motherhood: the end of a final taboo?
Talking Point Hettie Judah's new touring exhibition offers a 'riveting riposte' to old cliches
By Chas Newkey-Burden, The Week UK Published
-
Best music albums: new releases of 2024
The Week Recommends A round-up of the best pop, dance, indie, classical and rock releases
By The Week UK Published
-
Indie film's 'very brief' use of AI sparks backlash and calls for boycotts
Talking Points Did the creators of a new horror movie make a deal with the artificial intelligence devil?
By Rafi Schwartz, The Week US Published