Judge issues injunction on DHS use of force
Agents can only use force under the ‘immediate threat of physical harm’
What happened
U.S. District Judge Sara Ellis Thursday issued a heavily anticipated injunction against the Department of Homeland Security’s use of force during Operation Midway Blitz in Chicago. Her ruling bars DHS agents from using tear gas and other crowd-control weapons unless doing so would be “necessary” to stop the “immediate threat of physical harm.”
Who said what
The injunction refines and “extends” the temporary restrictions Ellis put in place against DHS last month, said The New York Times. Among other measures, yesterday’s ruling requires agents to “wear body cameras” and “give at least two audible warnings” before using crowd-control weaponry. “I see little reason for the use of force that the federal agents are currently using,” said Ellis. It “shocks the conscience.”
Delivering her ruling, the judge listed a “litany of incidents” in which civilians in Chicago were “tear-gassed ‘indiscriminately’, beaten and tackled by agents and struck in the face with pepper-spray balls,” said the Chicago Tribune. Ellis also accused Border Patrol Commander Gregory Bovino of giving evidence in his deposition testimony that she said was “simply not credible.” Justice Department attorneys had attempted to frame the case as “allowing law enforcement to do its job in the face of agitators who conflate constitutional rights with violent action,” said the Tribune.
The Week
Escape your echo chamber. Get the facts behind the news, plus analysis from multiple perspectives.
Sign up for The Week's Free Newsletters
From our morning news briefing to a weekly Good News Newsletter, get the best of The Week delivered directly to your inbox.
From our morning news briefing to a weekly Good News Newsletter, get the best of The Week delivered directly to your inbox.
What next?
Speaking from the bench before issuing her order, Ellis said that DHS’s illegal conduct showed “no signs of stopping.” The Trump administration was expected to appeal the ruling.
-
The best dark romance books to gingerly embrace right nowThe Week Recommends Steamy romances with a dark twist are gaining popularity with readers
-
The ocean is getting more acidic — and harming sharks’ teethUnder the Radar ‘There is a corrosion effect on sharks’ teeth,’ a study’s author said
-
6 exquisite homes for skiersFeature Featuring a Scandinavian-style retreat in Southern California and a Utah abode with a designated ski room
-
Trump sues JPMorgan for $5B over ‘debanking’Speed Read Trump accused the company of closing his accounts for political reasons
-
Minnesota roiled by arrests of child, church protestersSpeed Read A 5-year-old was among those arrested
-
Migrant death in ICE custody ruled homicideSpeed Read Geraldo Lunas Campos, 55, died of asphyxia, the coroner said
-
ICE memo OKs forcible entry without warrantSpeed Read The secret memo was signed last May
-
Washington grapples with ICE’s growing footprint — and futureTALKING POINTS The deadly provocations of federal officers in Minnesota have put ICE back in the national spotlight
-
DOGE shared Social Security data, DOJ saysSpeed Read The Justice Department issued what it called ‘corrections’ on the matter
-
Halligan quits US attorney role amid court pressureSpeed Read Halligan’s position had already been considered vacant by at least one judge
-
DOJ subpoenas Minnesota Democrats in legal escalationSpeed Read Several officials, including Gov. Tim Walz, were subpoenaed
