As the ultimate arbiters of US law, on whose rulings presidential elections can hang, supreme court justices are meant to be models of integrity and impartiality, said Ankush Khardori in Politico.
Who, now, could claim that Justice Samuel Alito fits that description? He has attracted criticism in the past for going on luxury holidays with conservative donors who have business before the court; he also allegedly leaked the result of a major case to conservative activists before the decision was announced. And he now stands accused of flying insurrectionist flags linked to the far-right.
The Week
Escape your echo chamber. Get the facts behind the news, plus analysis from multiple perspectives.
Sign up for The Week's Free Newsletters
From our morning news briefing to a weekly Good News Newsletter, get the best of The Week delivered directly to your inbox.
From our morning news briefing to a weekly Good News Newsletter, get the best of The Week delivered directly to your inbox.
No cause for controversy
Liberals are clutching at straws, said The Wall Street Journal. It was apparently Alito's wife who raised these flags – and there was no sinister intent. She flew the first one during a feud with an abusive neighbour (an inverted Stars and Stripes is an international signal of distress).
As for the "Appeal" flag, it was used in the revolutionary war and references a 1689 work by John Locke about the right to overthrow tyranny. Just because "some bozos brought it to the 6 January Capitol riot", it doesn't mean that it and Alito are extremist.
To listen to critics, you'd think Alito was flying a swastika, said Dan McLaughlin in National Review. The "Appeal" flag was personally approved by George Washington in 1775 and, until this week, had flown at San Francisco's City Hall without controversy for 60 years.
Alarm bell for voters
To claim that flying this flag proves Alito has become "a Maga radical" is a stretch, agreed Jonah Goldberg on The Dispatch. But regardless of his motivation, for a supreme court justice to have an inverted Stars and Stripes outside his house was "legitimately" seen as weird.
At the least, it suggested the appearance of inappropriate partiality. For that reason alone, Alito should recuse himself from hearing Trump's election cases, said Ruth Marcus in The Washington Post. He knew the upside-down flag was inappropriate.
"As soon as I saw it, I asked my wife to take it down," he'd said (it seems she refused to do so, for several days). "If he was alarmed then", American voters have "every reason to be alarmed now".
-
Will Netanyahu get a pardon?Today's Big Question Opponents say yes, if he steps down
-
December’s books feature otherworldly tales, a literary icon’s life story and an adult royal rompThe Week Recommends This month's new releases include ‘The Heir Apparent’ by Rebecca Armitage and ‘Tailored Realities’ by Brandon Sanderson
-
Trump boosts gas cars in fuel economy rollbackspeed read Watering down fuel efficiency standards is another blow to former President Biden’s effort to boost electric vehicles
-
The military: When is an order illegal?Feature Trump is making the military’s ‘most senior leaders complicit in his unlawful acts’
-
Ukraine and Rubio rewrite Russia’s peace planFeature The only explanation for this confusing series of events is that ‘rival factions’ within the White House fought over the peace plan ‘and made a mess of it’
-
The US-Saudi relationship: too big to fail?Talking Point With the Saudis investing $1 trillion into the US, and Trump granting them ‘major non-Nato ally’ status, for now the two countries need each other
-
Nigel Farage: was he a teenage racist?Talking Point Farage’s denials have been ‘slippery’, but should claims from Reform leader’s schooldays be on the news agenda?
-
Tariffs: Will Trump’s reversal lower prices?Feature Retailers may not pass on the savings from tariff reductions to consumers
-
American antisemitismFeature The world’s oldest hatred is on the rise in U.S. Why?
-
Trump: Is he losing control of MAGA?Feature We may be seeing the ‘first meaningful right-wing rebellion against autocracy of this era’
-
US government shutdown: why the Democrats ‘caved’In the Spotlight The recent stalemate in Congress could soon be ‘overshadowed by more enduring public perceptions’
