UK election 2024: Rishi Sunak's annus horribilis?

Winning a fifth term after 14 years in power is a tall order and few expect Tories to manage it

Rishi Sunak
Critics say if Sunak wants to campaign on 'real achievements' rather than 'illusory ones', holding fire is sensible
(Image credit: Getty Images)

Jeremy Hunt's announcement that the spring Budget will take place on 6 March – earlier than expected – prompted speculation that the Government plans to call an election in May to take advantage of voter goodwill created by any new tax cuts. 

But senior Tories dismissed the idea: Rishi Sunak said on Thursday that his "working assumption" was that it would take place "in the second half of this year". 

Subscribe to The Week

Escape your echo chamber. Get the facts behind the news, plus analysis from multiple perspectives.

SUBSCRIBE & SAVE
https://cdn.mos.cms.futurecdn.net/flexiimages/jacafc5zvs1692883516.jpg

Sign up for The Week's Free Newsletters

From our morning news briefing to a weekly Good News Newsletter, get the best of The Week delivered directly to your inbox.

From our morning news briefing to a weekly Good News Newsletter, get the best of The Week delivered directly to your inbox.

Sign up

'Prospects look bleak'

The prospects look bleak for the Government, agreed The Daily Telegraph. When the PM promised last January to reduce the NHS backlog, there were 7.2 million people on waiting lists; now, there are 7.7 million. Debt as a share of GDP is rising, not falling. The one blessing is that the Tories are now at least debating how best to cut taxes.

All is not lost for the Tories, said the Daily Mail. Inflation is falling and a report by accountants PwC finds the UK's outlook is "far rosier" than expected. If Sunak can convince voters that he has a credible strategy to get the public sector working again, he's in with a shot.

Going to the polls on 2 May, when there are local elections in nearly all of England and Wales, would have had some advantages. It would have averted accusations that Sunak was "clinging on", and helped bring out the vote. Waiting until the autumn could also cost the party votes, as more households come off their fixed-rate mortgages and have to renew at higher rates.

'Hope something turns up'

But there would have been dangers, too, with a May election, said Isabel Hardman in The Guardian. "The Budget-as-starting-gun theory relies largely on that fiscal event going well." And as the Tories know to their cost, they don't always do so, even when they include tax cuts.

In his Autumn Statement, Hunt proudly unveiled some tax cuts, while glossing over the stealth taxes imposed by freezing tax thresholds, said Fraser Nelson in The Daily Telegraph. If the Tories repeat that trick in March, in the hope of winning a pre-election bounce, it won't work. Sunak is wise to hold off the election until the end of the year, by which time some recent benign trends should have become more evident. Migration, inflation, mortgage rates, waiting lists and small-boat arrivals are now "on the way down".

If Sunak wants to campaign on "real achievements" rather than "illusory ones", holding fire is sensible. Sunak has only been PM for little more than a year, said John Curtice in the Daily Express, and he knows that election defeat will spell the end of his political career. So he has every reason to sit tight and "hope that something turns up before the autumn".