'De-influencers' are telling TikTok users what not to buy

For the past few years, influencer marketing has dramatically shifted how brands connect with consumers. With just one video or post, popular content creators can turn anything from a beauty product to a water bottle into a viral sensation, especially on TikTok. But recently, some content creators have started to take another route, using their platform to tell users what not to buy. They're calling it "de-influencing." Here's everything you need to know:

What is de-influencing?

De-influencing "refers to people speaking critically about products on a platform where endorsements run rampant," The Wall Street Journal explains. De-influencing videos may encourage consumers to consider cheaper alternatives to high-end viral products or "discourage them from spending money in certain categories altogether." Such videos are an antithesis "to a seemingly endless stream of recommendations and promotional content, and "a sign of growing backlash to overconsumption."

The de-influencing trend "is a stark contrast to prior ones like #TikTokMadeMeBuyIt, when consumers were showing off products they purchased after seeing them on the social media app," The Associated Press says. Brands have invested heavily in influencer marketing in recent years, given how effective one viral video can be. Videos tagged with #TikTokMadeMeBuyIt have reached over 40 billion views, while videos with #deinfluencing have garnered over 220 million.

Subscribe to The Week

Escape your echo chamber. Get the facts behind the news, plus analysis from multiple perspectives.

SUBSCRIBE & SAVE

Sign up for The Week's Free Newsletters

From our morning news briefing to a weekly Good News Newsletter, get the best of The Week delivered directly to your inbox.

From our morning news briefing to a weekly Good News Newsletter, get the best of The Week delivered directly to your inbox.

Sign up

Jenna Drenten, associate professor of marketing at Loyola University Chicago's Quinlan School of Business, told the Journal that initially, "influencers were very beholden to their audience" until brands started to partner with them to leverage their popularity. "Then, influencers became super beholden to brands." The recent rise in de-influencing videos shows that "influencers are swinging back to the accountability between themselves and their audiences," Drenten said.

When did the trend start?

It's not entirely clear how the trend originated, but the Journal says one of the early TikTok videos with the de-influencing hashtag came from beauty influencer Maddie Wells. In 2020, she began discussing products she saw customers frequently return while working at Sephora and Ulta. In one video from September with 2.5 million views, Wells "name-drops the Ordinary's Peeling Solution and Too Faced's Better Than Sex mascara" as cosmetics that were often returned, "despite being frequently touted by beauty influencers," the Journal writes. "I'm calling this 'de-influencing,'" Wells says in the video.

Why is de-influencing so popular now?

Influencers say the trend took off last month, "propelled by macroeconomic stress" and "a long-brewing backlash against pay-to-play product reviews," The Los Angeles Times reports. And a recent scandal wherein a TikTok beauty influencer wore false lashes in a sponsored video meant to promote a L'Oreal mascara "added more fuel to the fire."

"There's a theme of over-consumption when it comes to social media, and I think people are starting to notice just how detrimental it is towards our wallets and the environment," de-influencer Karen Wu said in an email to the Times. "Add in the economic downturn, and … consumers are starting to grow tired of the rhetoric that they NEED every viral product they see."