The risks and rewards of retail politics
Candidates are weighing whether pressing the flesh will help or hurt their chances in the social media era


A free daily digest of the biggest news stories of the day - and the best features from our website
Thank you for signing up to TheWeek. You will receive a verification email shortly.
There was a problem. Please refresh the page and try again.
By now, you've likely seen them — the short clips of Florida Republican Governor and presumptive 2024 GOP presidential candidate Ron DeSantis uncomfortably laughing just a bit too hard at some innocuous comment in Iowa or stumbling his way through awkward introductions at a New Hampshire diner. His unguarded moments are "what it looks like when the joker gas hits," quipped columnist Oliver Willis. He's "maybe the worse retail politician ever," added longtime political consultant Keith Edwards.
But for all his high-profile and well-reported struggles with small-scale interpersonal interactions, DeSantis is far from the only elected official to wade into the choppy waters of retail politics, eschewing — or at least temporarily superseding — hands-off campaigning on social media and at large-scale rallies, with a "more meaningful" presence full of "eye-to-eye contact," and "shaking hands, the really getting to know people, and them getting to know you," as GOP candidate Nikki Haley explained to Politico in Iowa. Even President Joe Biden, possessor of perhaps the largest soapbox on Earth, is leaning heavily into retail politics during his reelection campaign, particularly through brand association, which offers him "a way to locate [himself] in the country's cultural and social landscape," explained University of Virginia Miller Center presidential historian Russell Riley.
High risk, high reward
Consider Biden, a "retail politics virtuoso" and "the only politician of his kind," as The Atlantic's Edward-Isaac Dovere put it during the 2020 campaign. Like former President Bill Clinton and, to a degree, George W. Bush as well, Biden's skill at retail politics has helped establish a career-long public persona as a "shake-your-hand, pat-you-on-the-back kind of guy," according to Pennsylvania AFL-CIO President Rick Bloomingdale. That impression is crucial among voters whose impressions of various candidates otherwise "develop from a mixture of media coverage, preexisting partisan preferences, word-of-mouth and gut instinct," Monash University Journalism school lecturer Stephanie Brookes wrote in 2013. Moreover, while the primary recipient of retail politics is the person being politicked to, "there is a secondary audience: others who are present, those who hear about the meeting through word of mouth, and, increasingly, the broader media audience." While retail politicians operate one-on-one, the impact of that meeting — particularly in an era where every interaction is filmed, streamed, clipped, remixed and analyzed — goes far beyond the personal space in which the specific conversation takes place. Put another way, the benefits of retail politics are twofold: There are the "hard" gains of actively engaging with and hopefully convincing a voter to support you, as well as the "soft" gains of helping craft a broader public persona and national narrative.
Subscribe to The Week
Escape your echo chamber. Get the facts behind the news, plus analysis from multiple perspectives.

Sign up for The Week's Free Newsletters
From our morning news briefing to a weekly Good News Newsletter, get the best of The Week delivered directly to your inbox.
From our morning news briefing to a weekly Good News Newsletter, get the best of The Week delivered directly to your inbox.
This, of course, makes retail politics a risky proposition and something of a high-wire act — a lesson DeSantis and Haley both seem to be learning of late, thanks to the virality of their respective retail missteps, including most recently an attempt by Haley to rouse a New Hampshire breakfast crowd with anti-LGBTQ+ culture war rhetoric, only to be met with silence from the assembled diners. If "voters like and know more about the candidates whom they meet, but they also are more likely to experience contact with candidates whom they are predisposed to like," as Lynn Vavreck, Constantine J. Spiliotes and Linda L. Fowler wrote in the American Journal of Political Science, then the inherent risks involved are apparent: Not only are awkward encounters likely to turn off the most readily gettable voters, but in an era of ubiquitous social media virality they can appear more damning to third-party observers who have not self-selected to meet with the politician themselves. As much as retail politicking can help a campaign, particularly in primary races where small-scale interactions play a crucial role in not only setting the tone for a candidate but actively whipping votes, it can also detract from a candidate's intended persona and turn away supporters.
Will it matter in November?
Noting DeSantis' reputation as "a cold, prickly a**hole," The Dispatch's Sarah Isgur took a step back recently, asking the broader question of "whether voters will care." In other words, do "retail politics matter anymore?"
As Isgur points out, neither Donald Trump nor Barack Obama is considered a particularly effective retail politician, with the former eschewing rope lines and baby-kissing and the latter "known as a wonk who had difficulty connecting in small groups." Still, their respective presidential victories, predicated on what Isgur describes as a "preternatural" skill at large-scale oration, suggest that retail deficiencies can be overcome by other campaign tactics. In DeSantis' case, that means maximizing "negative attention on issues that he thinks will galvanize his supporters" while appealing to "a lot of GOP bigwigs … happy to support a moldy loaf of bread if it means retiring Donald Trump."
Trump himself, meanwhile, has abandoned retail politics entirely, basing his campaign not on an effort, practiced or natural, to make an empathetic connection with voters but instead on using "a moment of maximum crisis and disorder" to present himself as "a figure who stands apart from the crowd, positioned to swoop in and take command," Joanna Weiss wrote in Politico during the 2020 race. Even when he roils his base during stadium rallies, "it's not based on feeling the pain of their personal circumstances but rather expressing and validating their anger," agreed Randolph-Macon College political science professor Elliott Fullmer in the same piece.
Even Biden, a retail politician par excellence, was forced to abandon much of the intimacy and proximity he had spent years honing during the 2020 presidential race, as the ongoing Covid-19 pandemic upended many traditional modes of campaigning. Of the many factors involved in his victory that year, his ability to transcend the limitations of retail politics upon which he relied for so long is certainly among them.
This brings us back to DeSantis, whose allies in the Never Back Down super-PAC have reportedly raised a staggering $200 million to ensure he "beat[s] Trump by beating Trump," PAC chair Jeff Roe told The New York Times. The group is leaning heavily into its brand of retail politics, amassing an army of volunteers and organizers, as the "peer-to-peer, neighbor-to-neighbor conversation and conversion is going to be extremely important" for the candidate, particularly in the early primary states. While DeSantis may struggle with the optics of retail politics, his allies seem to understand that ultimately there's nothing quite like it on the path to the White House.
Continue reading for free
We hope you're enjoying The Week's refreshingly open-minded journalism.
Subscribed to The Week? Register your account with the same email as your subscription.
Sign up to our 10 Things You Need to Know Today newsletter
A free daily digest of the biggest news stories of the day - and the best features from our website
Rafi Schwartz is a Politics Writer with The Week, where he focuses on elections, Congress, and the White House. He was previously a contributing writer with Mic, a senior writer with Splinter News, and the managing editor of Heeb Magazine. His work has appeared in Rolling Stone, GOOD, The Forward, and elsewhere.
Rafi currently lives in the Twin Cities, where he does not bike, run, or take part in any team sports. He does, however, have a variety of interests, hobbies, and passions.
-
What to know when filing a hurricane insurance claim
The Explainer A step-by-step to figure out what insurance will cover and what else you can do beyond filing a claim
By Becca Stanek Published
-
How fees impact your investment portfolio — and how to save on them
The Explainer Even seemingly small fees can take a big bite out of returns
By Becca Stanek Published
-
Enemy without
Cartoons
By The Week Staff Published
-
Will the US keep aiding Ukraine?
Today's Big Question Republicans give Volodymyr Zelenskyy a 'cold shoulder' in D.C.
By Joel Mathis Published
-
Hunter Biden: a case of special treatment?
Why everyone's talking about If Hunter's surname weren't Biden, he probably wouldn't be facing these charges, say commentators
By The Week Staff Published
-
The states of statewide gerrymandering in 2023
In Depth Two extreme examples to watch ahead of the upcoming elections
By Rafi Schwartz Published
-
Should cognitive testing be a presidential prerequisite?
Today's Big Question A growing chorus of pundits and candidates are pushing mental fitness challenges as a campaign necessity
By Rafi Schwartz Published
-
Disunited nations: has the UN lost its relevance?
Missing figures at UN General Assembly lead to broad questions about the organisation's credibility
By Arion McNicoll Published
-
Trump's rhetoric rankles the anti-abortion movement
Why Trump's latest comments "may be the single biggest issue that leads him to lose in 2024"
By Joel Mathis Published
-
Donald Trump's Rosh Hashanah message to 'liberal Jews' reignites antisemitism debate
Was targeting his critics who 'voted to destroy America & Israel' the right way to mark the High Holidays?
By Rafi Schwartz Published
-
What might a post-Mitch McConnell GOP look like?
Here's what to watch for as questions about the longtime Senate leader swirl.
By Rafi Schwartz Published