Facebook leak reveals rules for controversial content

Videos depicting gory violence and even deaths may be allowed to remain on Facebook under some circumstances, according to leaked training manuals for the site's moderators.

In an exclusive report, The Guardian reveals the guidelines explicitly detailing the site's response to content containing sex, nudity, violence or death - a balancing act between protecting users from graphic material and maintaining Facebook's status as an open platform which can play a vital part in spreading awareness of issues.

Among them is a proviso stating "videos of abortion only violate if they contain nudity", while another says adult nudity is permissible in content showing Nazi concentration camps.

The Week

Escape your echo chamber. Get the facts behind the news, plus analysis from multiple perspectives.

SUBSCRIBE & SAVE

Sign up for The Week's Free Newsletters

From our morning news briefing to a weekly Good News Newsletter, get the best of The Week delivered directly to your inbox.

From our morning news briefing to a weekly Good News Newsletter, get the best of The Week delivered directly to your inbox.

Sign up

According to the manual on graphic violence, "sadism" is the key factor in deciding whether violent footage should be removed.

If images or videos show the wounding or death of a person or animal with a title or caption suggesting enjoyment or celebration, the content should be deleted, says Facebook.

However, while videos of violence or death are "disturbing", moderators are told to be aware that they may also be a means of "documenting atrocities" and can "help create awareness" of issues such animal cruelty or non-sexual child abuse.

Videos in this category are marked as "disturbing" and do not auto-play. They also contain a warning screen and are not accessible to users under the age of 18.

Content related to self-harm must always be flagged up to senior managers, the Guardian reports. A two-week period last summer saw 4,531 such cases, of which 63 prompted Facebook to contact the authorities.

The training manual also says Facebook Live streams showing self-harm or suicide attempts should not be shut down, despite the service being criticised for being used to broadcast sexual assaults, torture, murder and suicide.

Facebook says it is wary of cutting users off from friends who may be able to offer support or intervene to keep them safe in a time of trouble.

"We don't want to censor or punish people in distress who are attempting suicide," says a memo sent to site moderators.

Another document adds: "Users post self-destructive content as a cry for help, and removing it may prevent that cry for help from getting through."

However, moderators are told the content should be deleted after "there is no longer an opportunity to help the person" and minimise the risk of encouraging copycat behaviour, unless they are considered particularly newsworthy, such as footage of 9/11 which shows people leaping from the Twin Towers.

The leak "gives new insights into the uncomfortable role the social media giant now plays as a content regulator," says CNN.