Should wildlife crews intervene to save animals they are filming?
Latest episode of BBC’s Dynasties ignites fierce debate as David Attenborough weighs in
David Attenborough has waded in to a debate about whether wildlife photographers should intervene to help the animals they are filming.
The veteran presenter backed a decision by the crew of the BBC’s latest nature series Dynasties, to dig steps out of a ravine to save a group of penguins they had been following.
Following Sunday’s episode, Mike Gunton, the series executive producer, told BBC Radio 5 Live that 99.9% of the time it was not appropriate to intervene.
Subscribe to The Week
Escape your echo chamber. Get the facts behind the news, plus analysis from multiple perspectives.
Sign up for The Week's Free Newsletters
From our morning news briefing to a weekly Good News Newsletter, get the best of The Week delivered directly to your inbox.
From our morning news briefing to a weekly Good News Newsletter, get the best of The Week delivered directly to your inbox.
“It's such an unusual circumstance to do this,” he said, “and there are lots of situations where you couldn't, and shouldn't and wouldn't – but I think in this situation there were so many factors”.
“I was speaking to David about it yesterday and he said he would have done the same too”, he added.
The Daily Mail described the move as “unprecedented”, but both Attenborough and the BBC have a checkered history when it comes to the issue.
In 2013, Attenborough defended the decision to film the death of a baby elephant in the BBC's Africa series, saying it was “very important” to simply observe.
The Daily Telegraph reported that harrowing scene drew complaints from upset viewers, “some of whom hoped filmmakers would provide the dying calf with help”.
While the latest decision to step in and help the penguins drew praise on social media, others worry it could set a dangerous precedent.
Doug Allan, a cameraman behind some of the most famous wildlife scenes in television history, has said: “For me, at least, my job is to look and not interfere. If I feel my presence is tilting the balance of the predator or the prey, then I'm doing something wrong.”
In 2015 Martin Hughes-Games, who presents Springwatch and Autumnwatch, said there had been “absolute uproar” after the team helped with a flooded birds nest.
Speaking at the Radio Times Festival in London, he said: “Half the people said “why didn’t you intervene,” and others then said, “you shouldn’t have intervened”.”
“You’re damned whatever you do”, says The Metro.
“Step in and save an animal’s life, and you’re interfering with nature, which you’re supposed to be capturing authentically. But the alternative is to watch creatures die in front of you.”
BBC Dynasties director Will Lawson, cameraman Lindsay McCrae and assistant Stefan Christmann said they had unanimously “opted to intervene passively”.
“There’s no rule book in those situations. You can only respond to the facts that are right there in front of you”, he told The Times.
Create an account with the same email registered to your subscription to unlock access.
Sign up for Today's Best Articles in your inbox
A free daily email with the biggest news stories of the day – and the best features from TheWeek.com
-
'Making a police state out of the liberal university'
Instant Opinion Opinion, comment and editorials of the day
By Harold Maass, The Week US Published
-
8 looming climate tipping points that imperil our planet
The Explainer New reports detail the thresholds we may be close to crossing
By Devika Rao, The Week US Published
-
Try 6 free issues of The Week Junior
Spark your child's curiosity with The Week Junior - the award-winning current affairs magazine for 8-14s.
By The Week Published
-
Kerala: one Indian state, four exhilarating ways
The Week Recommends The southwestern region pretty much has it all, from beachfront, to port metropolis, to verdant mountainside
By Scott Hocker, The Week US Published
-
Aitch or haitch: the linguisitic debate that 'matters a lot'
Talking Point 'University Challenge' host Amol Rajan has promised to change the way he pronounces the letter 'H'
By Chas Newkey-Burden, The Week UK Published
-
The Secret Army: the IRA propaganda film forgotten for almost 50 years
Why Everyone's Talking About 'Chilling' BBC documentary reveals how US TV crew documented the inner workings of paramilitary group in 1970s
By Chas Newkey-Burden, The Week UK Published
-
Inseparable Sisters: uplifting BBC documentary about conjoined twins
The Week Recommends A 'refreshingly human and optimistic' portrayal that balances reality with positivity
By The Week UK Published
-
Annie Nightingale obituary: the trailblazing DJ who was Radio 1's longest-serving presenter
Obituary The first female DJ on BBC Radio 1, Nightingale paved the way for Annie Mac, Jo Whiley, Zoe Ball, Sara Cox and many more
By The Week Staff Published
-
How to plan an unforgettable trip to Antarctica
The Week Recommends Everything you need to know about planning an adventure on the ice
By Catherine Garcia, The Week US Published
-
Doctor Who: 60 years of time-travelling tomfoolery
Why Everyone's Talking About Special episodes celebrate show's past as Whovians look forward to new seasons ahead
By Julia O'Driscoll, The Week UK Published
-
Jimmy Savile: is The Reckoning a dramatisation too far?
Talking Point Steve Coogan's BBC series deemed a 'lurid story told mainly for ratings'
By The Week Staff Published